Monday, January 12, 2026

1/28, part 2…Democracy and Schooling (note, this post was added because of weather)

Now that you have watched the entirety of What is Democracy?, please post a comment about why you think I had you watch this film and what sort of connections you see between democracy and schooling/teaching. Note: you can refer to the film if you want or you can write about whatever other connections you see between the two. Either way, please use this space to think about the possible democracy-education relationships.  

28 comments:

  1. I think we watched this film to learn about the interconnectedness between democracy as a form of government and democracy as a way of life in society, specifically in schools. I think the film had two important moments that explored why education is necessary in a democracy and why democracy is necessary in an education. First, the medical professionals interviewed at the Miami trauma center, after discussing the dangers of extreme inequality and wealth disparities, unanimously agreed that if they could fix all the social issues in the U.S., they would funnel more funding towards public education. I have to agree. I think there is a clear connection between quality, affordable education providing equal opportunities to every student, and decreasing poverty, homelessness, violence, etc. A lot of individuals interviewed in this film talked about democracy as meaning freedom to them. I think education, if done right, can provide an avenue for freedom because, like Labaree talked about, education can lead to social mobility.
    The second important scene was the conversation with the group of Black students at a high school. Democratic practices like having opportunities to vote or voice your opinion or peacefully protest should be present in schools so students can experience and understand what democracy is on a small scale before they go out into the world. Instead, these students emphatically believed that their school was not a democracy. They thought their voices didn’t matter, and, in fact, when they rallied together to ask for improvements, like warm food in the cafeteria, they were punished. This feeling of helplessness and lack of autonomy in their education clearly wasn’t promoting enthusiasm to learn or positive relationships with their teachers. Additionally, when translated to a larger scale, this feeling of mistrust and lack of support from authority figures isn’t going to encourage students to have faith in the government, to vote, or positively participate in politics.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think you had us watch this film because it urges us to see democracy not as a fixed system but as an ongoing, changing practice that highly depends on participation and voice. In the education setting a democratic setting is rare, seen given by examples in the film and in my own personal experiences. I believe teachers have a huge role in shaping whether students learn to be simply obedient or engaged. Democracy in a classroom is about creating environments and situations where students can question power and feel like their voice is heard on difficult matters. This film showed me how relevant or how relevant democracy in education should be for the better of the education journey and in preparing students for life outside of schools. Schools are the foundation, building a person's attributes and skills. Without knowing what a proper democracy should look like our society will continue to stray away from trying to make voices heard.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that we watched this particular movie as part of a class on teaching because it forces us to think about the role of voice, the role of power, and the role of inclusion, which is a very important part of the teaching profession. The movie forces us to think about the role of voice in terms of power, which is important to the role of the teacher in the classroom. The movie forces us to think about the role of democracy as a process, which is important to the role of teaching as a process.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think we watched this film because it teaches us that democracy isn’t just about elections, but about who gets heard and who doesn’t. The film made me realize that democracy is something people have to fight for and take part in, not just something that works on its own. This connects to school because the classroom is one of the first places where students get an opportunity to have a say in what they do. When teachers let students ask questions and give their opinions, that’s practicing democracy. This gives students a way to learn how to participate in democracy instead of just following.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think this film shows us that democracy is more than just voting and how it is a system that constantly changing. The film helped me understand that democracy only works when people take part in it. This connects to school because the classroom is one of the first places where students learn to use their voice. When teachers let students share ideas and ask questions, they are practicing democracy. This helps students learn how to participate instead of just following rules.We watched this movie in a teaching class because it helps us think about voice, power, and inclusion. These are important parts of being a teacher. It also shows that teaching, like democracy, is a process that takes effort and participation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think we watched this film because it gave us a better understanding about democracy. We learned that democracy is a lot about people using their voices, and advocating for policies and change that they believe in. Democracy is not just about political elections and voting, its about using your voice and being heard. We can connect this to schools and classrooms because being a student its important for you to use your voice and have opinions to have a good learning atmosphere. At some schools we see that students get silenced and their opinions are not heard, which shows a lack of democracy. I think this film showed us the importance of using your voice and using democracy as an advantage, rather than being walked all over and just going with what your told.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I believe you had us watch the film because it creates an environment of discomfort with our understanding of "democracy" as a "given", and allows us to understand how democracy is an active, on-going, and fragile process; one that needs to be engaged in by all of us through continuous participation, criticism, and caring for its survival. The film does not limit the idea of democracy to voting or institutions, but rather to a struggle to determine who counts, who has a voice, and whose life matters. In addition to demonstrating the historical aspects of democracy, the film also demonstrates that the economic power and social inequalities have formed what democracy will look like today.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think you had us watch this documentary so we can get a better understanding of democracy from the outside and how it's not something that we are born with so, in order to learn democracy we need to do so through experience. This can be exercised in a class simply by allowing students to speak about how something makes them feel or even just giving students more options and say in the classroom. I honestly feel like this should be pushed for in all classrooms so kids can gain lots of strong skills and overall shape into confident students!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I believe that the reason we watching this is film is to teach us that democracy, politics itself, is a key part in the way we live, that breathing through every hallway of our life is democracy. Especially in the idea of becoming a public school teacher, the world we live in has made education, not a right but a stance of politics. This movie is to show us about democracy, and that by understand the broad sense of democracy would we be able to facilitate democratic equality. We need to be a role model about the power of the voice, teaching kids how to share their opinion and listen to others, to teach them about leading into change instead of idling and just watch from a distance.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think you had us watch this film because it shows that democracy isn’t just voting or laws, but about who gets a voice and who is ignored, something that you can see with todays education. Schools can either prepare students to think critically, ask questions, and participate in society, or they can just train us to follow rules and accept answers without pushing back. As a student, I notice that when teachers encourage discussion and different perspectives, it feels more democratic because everyone’s experiences matter. But when learning is only about memorizing for tests, it feels less like democracy and more like control. To me, the connection is that education shapes the kind of citizens we become, and if schools don’t value their own students' opinions about the world they’re actively living in, democracy can’t function the way it’s supposed to.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think the purpose of watching this film was to make us think more about the relationship between education and democracy because schools are one of the first places where we learn about things like authority, rules, and participation, and each one of those concepts is related to the way democracy is practiced in our society. Something I thought about while watching the film, which dealt with the concepts of voice and power, was the voice that students have in the classroom because usually schools emphasize obedience more than voice, but teaching is a democratic process when the student is encouraged to ask questions and voice his or her opinion. The film also makes us think about inequality, which is a very important concept that is related to education because not all students have the same opportunities, and all these concepts are related to the way democracy functions.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think you had us watch this film because of the current lack of democracy in learning spaces outside of higher education settings. The level of control that a student has over their educational experience has a great impact on the amount of success they experience. I’ve personally developed so much more and so much faster since entering college and gaining more control over my life. In the documentary, we can see the negative effects from a lack of democratic education with the interviewed students. They bring up valid issues over the lunches, talking about how the poor quality can impede education when students are too focused on hunger to learn, but they speak from the perspective of the defeated. The students explained how their complaints had been consistently ignored by faculty, damaging their trust in the system meant to help them and their confidence in their ability to impact their environment. If we foster students' voices and agency through democracy in schools, we give them a safe environment to develop critical thinking and social belonging.

    ReplyDelete
  13. As we discussed in class, I think you had us watch this documentary so we could all have a similar understanding about democracy, a basis of knowledge surrounding this complex topic. I also think this documentary is very relevant and it is very easy to make connections with what we watched to what we see happening politically today. I think another intention of yours was to have us start thinking about how we are connected to the system of democracy and how this will impact our future careers in school. Something that I was most surprised by in the documentary was the group of elementary schoolers that were interviewed. From personal experience and theirs, it is clear that democracy within schools is lacking, and the opinions of students should be taken into consideration and respected but it is common that the administration gets the privilege of the greatest voice in the system. These kids reflected on how their teachers not only fail to implement democracy but are even disrespectful. One girl commented on how she was told by a teacher that her grade didn’t matter because either way she got paid. I think as emerging educators we have to understand the influence we will one day have in a classroom. More than teaching, we also need to be a representation of the democracy we envision for the future, the one that this documentary highlights as beneficial. We have strayed away from this ideal democracy because of actions that show individuals their voice doesn’t matter, like how this teacher treated her student. What comes to my mind when thinking about democracy-education relationships is actually teaching about the concepts of equity and fairness so kids at any age can begin to understand what their rights are and create an expectation that they deserve respect too. What is really inspirational is how this young group of kids, despite feeling unsupported by their school, was able to speak up for themselves and therefore initiate change by voicing a problem and adding to this meaningful conversation around democracy created by this documentary.

    ReplyDelete
  14. We watched this film to help us get a insight into real issues that involve democracy that we may encounter while teaching. This film allowed us to understand different perspectives people have on democracy. During the film a lot of people had different opinions about democracy and what they believed democracy looked like. This can be helpful when I start teaching because it allows me to better understand what students and families are going through, which can be crucial to helping them feel comfortable and feel supported. Lastly, this film has opened my eyes to other democratic problems going on in other communities, and has taught me ways I can teach students how to be a member of a democratic society.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think you had us watch "What is Democracy?" to push us to think about democracy as something that is practiced rather than something that simply exists because of institutions like elections. One of the film’s central ideas is that democracy depends on who gets a voice and whose voices are taken seriously, which connects directly to schooling. School, in a way, is like a child's first experience with a government-like social system and hierarchy. It is political by a broader definition I found in the dictionary, "the assumptions or principles relating to or inherent in a sphere, theory, or thing..." We are all impacted by the values instilled in our youth. Drastic generational differences are quite evident, dictated by the education system at the time. Our responsibility as adults to afford children the privilege of innocence, without plaguing their minds with the horrors of current events that their underdeveloped brains are incapable of interpreting, is a responsibility that transcends the education system. The responsibility of education, then, is not to impose conclusions, but to provide students with the habits of thought and moral grounding needed to reach rational and compassionate conclusions later in life. This important step in raising our youth surpasses the education system as well, falling primarily on parents and reinforced by educators. This film highlights how education and democracy ARE deeply connected, of course, which should motivate us as teachers to provide generations to come with the skills to be empathetic and thoughtful.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think you had us watch this film so we could understand there is power in change and there is power in doing what you belive is right even ot the odds of political power. That in times of change to stick together and keep fighting. One connection I can make between the video and school system democracy is when the government of Greece said the people will choose but did the complete opposite of what they voted. Which in school teachers can ask what students think is best in the course their in and then maybe do the opposite and rule out what they said since they have the power to do that. I also think a good connection is the divide of people and how far that can take someone away from humanity. Being so divided and indifferent can make people look at others as trash rather than just a human with difference, same happens in school and in just the real world. I did really like this film since it shows that its not just in school or where you live but it is an on going problem everywhere so it makes you feel less alone or like youre helpless.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Emma Lucius-MillimanFebruary 1, 2026 at 6:24 AM

    My belief is that we watched this film to under stand the complex power of democracy and how we can apply that to our everyday lives.In education, democracy is used to make decisions based on: material taught, resources a student needs, and the environment of the educational space. Growing up, the educational systems seems to pin students against one another in competition and stereotypes. The United States education system was created systematically, the system well known for being less than inclusive of all backgrounds. It makes it hard to see the way that democracy has affected k-12 education for different individuals. Another things about democracy is that something that is established by democracy can also be taken away. For example, Michelle Obama created a different school lunch diet during 2010 that only stayed in affect until 2014. The kids who participated lives were impacted by a choice voted on by democracy. It's very interesting how the government and school system co-exist. Overall, the film was able show vast perspectives on the inner works of democracy which opens up the field to how it works in education.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I’m glad that we watched this video to start the semester. It pushed me to think beyond the idea of American democracy I have been taught and confront what democracy looks like in the present moment. The film asks us to ponder who democracy actually serves, who is excluded from it, and how power can be hidden beneath claims of equality. This line of thinking feels particularly relevant when considering public schools which are the cornerstone of democratic society.
    Schools are deeply tied to democracy, but they are also shaped by the economic systems they exist within. One text that helped me think through this connection and that I connected back to this prompt was Schooling in Capitalist America and a quote from the introductory chapter, “An educational system can be egalitarian and liberating only when it prepares youth for fully democratic participation in social life and an equal claim to the fruits of economic activity.” (Bowles and Gintis 14). Though schools claim to promote democratic values they often reproduce existing economic and social hierarchies that they exist in. Bowles and Gintis explain that it is difficult for schools existing in a capitalist society to foster democratic participation when inequality is built into the grander system.
    What stands out to me even more is how entrenched this tension is to our history. Listen to our own Founding Father, Benjamin Rush, “The government of schools... should be arbitrary. By this mode of education we prepare our youth for the subordination of laws and thereby qualify them for becoming good citizens of the republic. I am satisfied that the most useful citizens have been formed from those youth who have not known or felt their own wills til they were one and twenty years of age.” Interesting...! And eerily similar to the struggles of the students in the What is Democracy? documentary.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think we were told to watch this film because it showed how democracy is part of everyday life and is ever changing. There political democracy sure but it also exists within a classroom, a school, and a district. Teachers should ensure democracy exists in their classroom and have to be proactive about keeping it like that. The examples both in the film and from my k-12 experience is that the best teachers have a democratic classroom. They listen and pay attention to their students and find the best way to teach, meanwhile the worst teachers have a set plan they’ve used for the past 5 years and will continue to use for the next 10, these teachers do not make successful students. Grades can be perfect and behavior can be appropriate but the students don’t learn how to think critically and develop their sense of self with classrooms that try and fit everyone into a cookie cutter form. Schools are part of the foundation of building a person’s perception of the world and it’s important to show students that they can fight for the things they want and should follow anything or anyone with blind support or obedience.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I think you made us watch this movie to get a common definition of democracy that we will come back to throughout the semester. I think if we didn't all watch this movie and discussed the topics you would give us our discussions would go on for days. This film gave good perspectives that helped me understand why democracy can't be simply defined. Democracy ties to education because, like the kids in the film talked about, students deserve to have a voice in their education and environment so they can enjoy learning. Hearing so many perspectives opened my eyes to how important it is as a future educator to be open-minded because I don't know what people have gone through, and it motivates me to create a welcoming space in my future classroom where kids feel like they can speak up and be heard.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I think you had us watch this movie to build upon our basic understanding of democracy. This movie highlighted the complexities and constant evolving of democracy, showing that it can be interpreted and perceived differently for each individual. I learned that democracy can not be directly defined, as it is constantly evolving to fit our changing society. In regards to education, that is constantly shifting and changing as well. I think it is very important for teachers to include a sense of democracy in their classrooms to ensure that student voices are heard and supported in any way they can be. Teachers should be teaching children not just basic facts, but also how to form opinions and speak out for themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think we watched this to understand how democracy connects to school and teaching. The movie shows that democracy is about people having a voice, and school is one of the first places where students learn how to share ideas, ask questions, and listen to others. It also shows that not everyone has the same opportunities, and education helps people gain the knowledge and confidence to be involved in society. It made me think classrooms should feel more democratic, too, where students can speak up and participate instead of just sitting quietly.

    ReplyDelete
  23. We watched this documentary so that we could sort of make a connection with democracy and the way it involves itself in our school/education system. For an example democracy involves its way and is used in school during when students are expressing their multiple viewpoints to the teachers or their owner classmates, class votes, the students having the freedom to express their ideas, as well as students coming from all different backgrounds, voices, and etc.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I think the documentary was meant to give us a good grasp on democracy, while also showing how it connects to our own personal experiences and futures as teachers. Something that really stood out to me was the group of elementary students, because their stories showed how often student voices are ignored or disrespected in schools. I realize how important it is for me, as a future educator, to create classrooms where students feel heard and valued.

    ReplyDelete

3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)

  What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...