Can you give an example of an experience you have had as a student that seemed traditional? How about progressive? Please very briefly one or the other. Was it a good experience? Why or why not?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
-
React to this film. One possible topic is to relate this film to the recent CRT controversy.
One example of an experience in school that seemed traditional was when I got sent to the principal's office a bunch as a kid for things that honestly weren't super crazy. I think this is an example of a more traditional teaching practice because my teacher at the time did not care at all about my undiagnosed adhd, and did next to nothing in terms of collaborating with my parents to figure out what the actual issue was, but instead just kicked me out of the classroom whenever I annoyed her instead of proactively working to help me become a better student. This was definitely a bad experience because I was essentially getting singled out and picked on by my teacher because she thought I was annoying. One experience I've had as a student that seemed progressive was my experience with the Teachers For Tomorrow class, because it honestly felt like a really unique approach to learning how to teach.
ReplyDelete-calvin
ReplyDeleteI was taking a class last semester it was a very lecture-heavy class where the teacher just talked the entire period, students took notes, and success meant memorizing information for tests. I will say it was efficient for covering content, but there is no room for questions, discussion, or connecting the material to real life, which made learning feel passive and forgettable. I just don't understand how the teacher thinks they are going to make us learn like that. This was definitely was not a good experience at all.
ReplyDeleteA school experience that seemed traditional was going to high school football games. Although my high school was extremely terrible at football and we only won a few games of the season, it felt necessary to still go to the games. Teachers would talk about the games every Friday and ask who is going and then continue to talk about the results in Monday's class. My school was better at lacrosse and soccer than any of the other sports but still football got most of the attention and hype. I personally never really enjoyed the games because I never really was cheering for anything cause we kept losing but just the idea of dressing up for all the themes and going with friends made it worth it. Why football is so overhyped in high school, however, I will never understand.
ReplyDeleteProgressive experiences I had in school was in my art classes or when we got to pick the topic of our projects in other classes like English. In art the teacher taught us about the medium we were using and then opened the floor up to us being able to create something with it of our own choosing. I liked using my creativity and having free will on a project which isn't always the option for other classes that stick to the books following traditional guidelines.
DeleteA school experience that seemed tradition for me was singing for the choir. Even though I'm a singer, I've never been able to really fit into a choir. My voice type doesn't tend to blend in choirs as well, so every time that choir would be asked to preform I'd get very nervous. I can recall times were I barely sung at all in fear of my classmates hearing the difference. If my school had a option for a different music development class there's a big chance I would've chosen that class throughout high school. Instead I did choir for a year and stopped singing all together. It wasn't a horrible experience, it just didn't help me grow my voice which was frustrating. Schools should consider having more arts options. K-12 schools tend to hyper fixate on athletics but theatre and preforming can get just as many trophies. My high school won states in multiple preforming categories most years and yet they put all there money into sports, it was aggravating.
ReplyDeleteI believe that most of my educational experiences so far have been fairly traditional. One specific example was during a study hall in middle school, where the proctor was incredibly strict and enforced what the video described as the “ideal” traditional student: docile, obedient, and quiet. We had to quietly sit at our desks and do homework. We couldn’t do anything collaborative with fellow students or ask clarifying questions; we couldn’t even leave the classroom unless it was for something the teacher qualified as important. I remember one time asking to go to the bathroom, and the teacher responded, saying, “No, you should have planned wisely and gone to the bathroom before study hall started.” I was livid that this teacher thought he could exert so much authority over me that he could even restrict access to a bathroom. This experience was definitely an extreme example of a traditional education tactic, but it did not promote a positive relationship between myself and the teacher. As a result, I didn’t feel supported or prone to growth in that environment and instead dreaded it.
ReplyDeleteMy last education class is what comes to my mind when I think about a progressive learning environment. We had a textbook but the professor used class time to allow opinions, thoughts and questions to be shared and discussed amongst the class. The class wouldn’t have worked without student inquiry and everyone's ideas were interesting as we talked about deep topics such as racism in schools, redistricting, the effect of economics on education and opportunity gaps created among students based on external factors. I learned so much from this class by listening and doing research with a group to purposefully question the success and failures of schools around Richmond. I also learned so much about Richmond’s history with the majority of it having happened within decades or is still happening currently. In a traditional classroom, learning about more recent events would become a lost opportunity due to textbooks not being able to provide a continued story about what the past has influenced in our communities today. Overall, I think a progressive learning approach is very beneficial to student learning especially in college because young adults should also have the chance to practice inquiry.
ReplyDeleteI can recall scenarios where I've experienced both progressive & traditional learning during my sophomore year of highschool. In my chemistry class, my teacher would read down slides and have us complete fill in the blank study guides. Though we had many opportunities for experiments, our success in class mainly relied on memorizing material. In my AP world history class, my teacher often threw out the concept of "memorization" & had us complete many group projects instead. We were given quizzes off textbooks, but my teacher strived for us to participate in class lessons about several historical events, our opinions, and even pushed us to even teach the concept to each other.
ReplyDelete- Jay
DeleteSomething traditional that I experienced in high school was a bathroom pass and one person at a time. I think that is something that should change especially in high school. I can understand it more in elementary school but as a teenager you should be able to go to the restroom whenever you need to as long as students take advantage of it.
ReplyDeleteBack in high school I took this physics class that was very progressive. The teacher would start of most lessons teaching us concepts and basic needed information, but then we would have to solve/figure out the equation ourselves on a whiteboard alongside our group. It was a collaborative effort between groupmates trying to pull in what we've know and what we've learned into 'discovering' these equations. Other than the lessons we would have frequent projects, one that was quite notable was the ones we did near the end of the year titled "wave labs". We would use these ripple tanks and follow instruction on changing the variables of frequency, amplification, strobe lights, and try figure out as a group what phenomena we were witnessing: patterns, refractions, etc...
ReplyDeleteI'd say while the learning was very enjoyable, retaining information wasn't practical in this class. At the end of the day you needed to know the equations effectively, quickly, and when it should be applied, and while we knew how to derive it, it wasn't preparing us for tests where we needed to instantly recognize it. This was the teacher's first year at this school and I do think that the teacher ended up revising her lesson plan so as to have more math focus/practice for test readiness.
DeleteA progressive experience I had as a student was in my Univ 299 class that I took during the Summer Scholars program and what made it feel so progressive to me was that it was graded much differently than most of my other classes. One way that it differed was that instead of relying on things like exams, tests, or quizzes, the class focused on and was graded by participation, reflection, and, really, just overall growth over time. I think this was a good experience and I really liked the class, and I think that's partly because of its reduced stress which helped me feel more motivated and involved in the class. It also made learning in that class feel a lot more personal and it encouraged me to think about what I was learning rather than just memorizing information.
ReplyDeleteAn example of a progressive type of education I’ve had is with group projects- taking what we’ve learned and expanding upon it with our own thoughts and ideas that connect to something in the real world. It was less about memorizing the content and more about seeing if we have the knowledge to apply what we knew in a real way. I enjoy this type of learning because you get to see in real time what you do and don’t understand about the concept when trying to put it in a real world scenario.
ReplyDeleteOne experience I have had as a student that was progressive was in some of my classes here at college. One way I noticed some of my classes were more progressive is because we had a lot more group discussion rather than lecture. In a lot of my classes this semester my professors strive for students to be active in the lesson and to give their thoughts and ideas as well. It also feels progressive because they will grade you on your participation as well. I personally like this style of class because rather than just listening to what the professor has to say or think, I can gage what my peers think as well.
ReplyDeleteIn my chemistry course in college, this experience was a bit traditional, to be honest, and quite boring because we were not able to practice our knowledge within the classroom. My success was based on how well I was able to take notes and how well I was able to recall information. In my Univ class, we were given a passage to read, then we were asked to have a conversation in groups with a leader from each group. This was a great experience, a progressive experience, because we were able to share ideas, make decisions, etc.
ReplyDeleteI experienced progressive teaching in my high school ceramics class. The teacher I had for this class was very nice and always active in class, which made class time fun and entertaining. In class we would learn about different topics in techniques that are in ceramics, and we would have to incorporate the technique that we learned into a ceramic creation of our choice. I enjoyed this class because we were able to create anything we wanted, and there were no limits to what you could make. I also like that this class had some structure because it gave us a guideline to follow and then encouraged us to branch out and be creative with our project.
ReplyDeleteI feel like an example that was very traditional was my bio 101 class I took in my first semester. It was very lecture notes nothing else for the period of class. The teacher read off the slides did not really interact more than teaching and it was really not a good traditional learning. Im not really a good lecture slides take notes learner. I like to be engaged and even hands on helps me a lot to learn. My ethics class I took this last semester was very progressive in my experience, there were no slides and just a handout with a lot of actual teaching. I learned so much and actually truly enjoyed that class only because it was taught in a way I could grasp.
ReplyDeleteI forgot to put my name Zoey Gunkel
DeleteThe first thing that comes to mind for traditional schooling experiences are the multiplication sheets we would have to do in my 4/5th grade math classes. We would be timed and the goal was to complete as many as we could in the allotted time, or finish the sheet. I’m not sure I would call it a good experience, but it was exhilarating and I suppose it helped me learn my multiplication tables. I’ve been wanting to do it again and see how well I do.
ReplyDeleteI think my experiences in the IB program gave me more access to a progressive education, at least a more progressive one than my standard or AP classes would have been. IB relied heavily on student-led discussions and the process of Inquiry, Action, and Reflection. This was definitely a good experience. Discussions in classes like English and Theory of Knowledge helped me understand and make new connections to the texts we were reading, because I was collaborating with my peers who had different ideas from my own. I loved the act of reflecting on my process, it was always required of us. Even if we weren’t happy with the outcome we were still able to think critically about the entire journey and what we would do differently next time.
I certainly did have a traditional teaching experience mostly through middle school actually, when the teacher would display notes on the board for us to copy down and would kind of barely speak giving us information in a kind of "boring" way. She would tell us facts about certain topics, assign us exams, etc. (like the traditional way) and overall while the experience wasn't absolutely horrible it was extremely boring and I wish the teacher had a little more effort when presenting assignments to us as her students. As for a progressive experience I had, my favorite teacher in High School would mostly leave it up to us on how to preform in class, he would have us go into smaller groups and discuss on what we thought about the notes or whatever topic we've learned that day and we would also do fun projects in class that mostly involved peer work. So I would ultimately say that I had a good experience in that class, and now that I look back at it, I kind of see it as a college success preparation class because we kind of worked at our own pace and decided on how we would perform in the class.
ReplyDeleteCaron Robinson
DeleteI took a teaching education class last semester and I genuinely has never felt so smart in my life. My professor always taught us through her voice, now what I mean by that is she didn't just read what was on the board but would expand on it in a way where we naturally would want to respond and then engage in the lesson.. which helped me so much because I'm not a traditional student, my brain likes to express it self through my voice and hands. I loved that class so much and really hope teachers always do this!
ReplyDeleteOne example of Tradition schooling in was a lot in high school where I would have teachers just lecture and we would take notes, then after a few weeks we would take tests for every 4-5 chapters. There was no room for questions really and it was very straight forward. Personally, it wasn't a negative experience, but I had a friend in class who did have a hard time because that was not their learning style and was more of a hands-on visual learner. I've had multiple instances of progressive example of progressive learning, especially in college. One instance was that every class students would work with one another every class to apply what we learn to the case study. I learned so much and I loved how interactive it was.
ReplyDeleteAn experience I've had as a student that was rather traditional was the test taking process, especially for AP classes. The tests always followed the same sort of format: multiple choice, short answer, and long answer, and allowed for little flexibility in testing students' skills. I very much did not like this test taking, as it lead to a lot of stress and time consumption.
ReplyDeleteOne example of traditional schooling I experienced in school was long lectures, where a teacher will just be talking and talking at the students, and expect them to take that and know the information. This doesn't work very well for most students because its not engaging at all, very boring and monotone. A progressive schooling experience I had was my teachers for tomorrow class, specifically junior year. I had an absolutely amazing teacher that encouraged us in many ways, was very open about the struggles of being a teacher, and made sure we got as much experience out in other schools as we could. She inspired me, and my goal as a teacher is to make my classroom just as comforting, open, and welcome as she did.
ReplyDeleteOne example of traditional school I have experienced is in a development and growth class I took last semester. The lecture was two hours and the professor talked the whole two hours with one 15 minute break. Our assignments concluded of discussion boards about videos we had to watch on our own, group projects and a paper as a final. I think I can speak for every college student when I say this is rarely effective, especially in a long class. We may be adults and are capable of sitting for two hours, but I don't think that it means we learn best like that. I could write so much about why progressive school is so beneficial with the little knowledge I have. My motivation to go to class is higher when I know the class is engaging. It is so easy for my mind to wander and lose track of the point when I don't have breaks to reflect on what I am learning about.
ReplyDelete-angelica arias
DeleteIn my Advanced Focus Inquiry course, we would often get a reading to complete outside of class then be given an open ended question to discuss about in small groups. This to me is a more progressive way to teach because we are expected to think critically as students and are not just handed information by the teacher. Overall, I felt neutral on this method of teaching. I enjoyed getting to share my individual thoughts, but I wish we got more guidance from the teacher.
ReplyDeleteGinna Durgavich
DeleteOne example of a traditional experience I had as a student was when the teacher mostly lectured while students just listened, took notes, and then completed worksheets or tests. There wasn’t much discussion or group work. It was okay, but sometimes it felt boring and harder to stay interested because we weren’t very involved. A more progressive experience I had was working on group projects where we could share ideas, solve problems together, and present our work. I liked that experience better because it helped me understand the material more and made learning feel more interactive.
ReplyDeleteI feel like my freshman year of college has a very traditional feel to it. Besides taking UNIV 111 and 112 all of my classes were lectures. The the professor stands and the front of the room and the students just take notes and complete tests every couple units. In these classes I just felt like a number, there was no real student - professor relationship that made learning enjoyable. Since then I have gotten into my core classes for my major and I absolutely love them. I am majoring in Health and Physical Education, so a lot of our work is collaborative and hands on. There are around 4-6 people in these classes and it allows us to have discussions frequently.
ReplyDeleteMy Catholic education was what I’d call a “traditional blend.” There were structured classrooms and sometimes memorization and an accelerated. At the same time, discussion and reflection were encouraged in theology and literature classes. I loved that environment because expectations were clear and consistent. I knew what mastery looked like, and I was pushed to meet it.
ReplyDeleteAfter COVID, I transferred to a very progressive private school. Deadlines were flexible and most assignments were graded for completion. While that approach may have been well-intentioned, I personally struggled without firm standards. I performed well enough at the time, but I was not being stretched. When I entered college, I realized I was underprepared for the level of rigor required.
My experience in public school fell somewhere in between. When the teachers were strong, even a traditional model worked well. When they were not, it felt like a watered-down version that gave us the stress without the true understanding of content.
Overall, I don’t think any one style of teaching is inherently flawed. Execution matters more than ideology. Some subjects, like math or chemistry, demand structured, objective instruction. Others, like literature or history, benefit from more open discussion and interpretation. I think many of us have experienced poor education and we've been taught to fear school, which conditions us to fear great knowledge. I hope I can be a teacher that is able to center my students and their goals and feelings in a more progressive way, but be able to provide them with truly rich knowledge through engaging and challenging curriculum. Our students shouldn't be afraid of school due to fear of failing ridiculous tests, or outside circumstances that don't dictate their mastery, but that doesn't mean we can't push them to work hard and crave success.
I thought I already did this but I cant find it...
ReplyDeleteI took a biolgy class my frist semester here and I thougt it was very traditinal, the teacher read off the slides, didnt really get to know any of the students, she didnt really seem to care to know us either. It was a very boring class and it was very straight forwarwd and I do not remember anything of it. It was very unengaging and not fun yet I took a ethics class where the teacher was very engaged and made jokes, talked to us and you could tell hw really cared about us learning and also our well being. I enjoyed that class very much and that class I leanred more than any other class ive taken here.
My K-12 schooling was full of both traditional and progressive schooling though since it was a very rural school it was mostly traditional. Until about 10th grade classes were primarily focused on memorization and aside from enforcing basic manners there was rarely any connection between the students and teachers. I was always a fairly good student so I don’t have too many bad memories about traditional teaching but as someone who will become a teacher I’ve often looked back at how traditional teaching affected other students. Traditional teaching was very hard on some kids because for those who werent “good” students it often made it so that the “bad” kids weren’t understood and were unfairly treated when they likely were just missing valuable connections at school. As for the few progressive experiences I had I’d say they came from electives instead of general education classes. My art teacher who I’ll likely be doing my teacher interview with was always open to making connections with students, while also establishing healthy boundaries. She would let us rest if we needed to and work on missing work or homework in her class because she understood it could be stressful for students who maybe didn’t have many opportunities to get work done due to sports, extracurriculars, or home situations. She was an amazing teacher and I have great memories of her class.
ReplyDelete