What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any other thoughts?
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...
This reading mostly focused on teaching in a way that fosters humanization vs in a way that fosters dehumanization. Ayers brings up several examples of dehumanizing teaching in movies and literature. He discusses how teaching can be used for oppression and control, in the forms of the residential schools that were forced upon indigenous populations in the Americas and Australia, as well as a book about a teacher in an American public school that dehumanizes his students. He writes about the Teachers' role in creating an ethical society, saying that teachers and school are students' first experiences with hierarchy, and also that if we completely discount their feelings and experiences that we are essentially handicapping the future generation by teaching them to reproduce the same injustices that they experienced growing up. Overall, this was a very interesting read, and I agreed with Ayers on many of his main arguments.
ReplyDeleteAyers writes about the importance of teaching as more than just passing on knowledge. He says it is a personal and intellectual act that requires judgment, reflection, and an understanding of the student's life. He says that it is an "enterprise" that is full of uncertainty, but it is a normal aspect of it, not a negative one. This helps people change their views of teaching from a controllable aspect of learning to one that must be changed all the time. Ayers also argues against the idea that there is a simple method for teaching. He says that teachers make decisions in the moment based on the circumstances, relationships, and values. Ayers also says that there is a moral and social aspect of teaching. He says that it is never a neutral act and always shows people's feelings about power and society. He says it is a meaningful but difficult task that requires creativity, responsibility, and reflection.
ReplyDeleteAyers comes across as very set in his beliefs when it comes to teaching but in a well rounded way, as he has thoroughly explored the many complicated aspects that define what it means to be a teacher. Because schools are set up to “induct the young” they also, according to Ayers, “enact partial answers to humanity’s enduring questions,” ones like, what is the meaning of life? This is why he focuses on the necessity that teachers should strive to teach kindness and partnership and also lead a classroom in a democratic way that promotes critical pedagogy. I agree with this, especially for younger grades. Establishing good morals is going to be the base of their education and life. I also believe that to do this, a progressive approach to teaching should be utilized so that critical thinking can begin as early as possible. Ayers criticizes the traditional approach and uses extreme examples from the past, such as Nazi Germany, to highlight the power of authoritarian rule. Despite the fact that today in a democratic society, an authoritarian structure in schools is wrong, Ayers argues that our school systems are still affected by past norms of teachers acting like a ruler in the classroom. He talks about the responsibility teachers have, “the task of humanization,” coming with the risk of effecting the opposite, dehumanization, which is what he believes the traditional approach to teaching does. Many times he expresses that being a teacher that uses critical pedagogy to create active citizens with good morals is much easier said than done because this process requires ethical decisions, which can be complicated and challenging. According to Ayers, “Ethical decisions are made through a process that is lonely, often intuitive, filled with despair and finally, courage.” I wouldn’t have necessarily thought about this potentially lonely process involving despair for teaching kindergarten but ethics are complicated, no matter what age you are working with. This point, along with his others in this chapter, are well thought out and truly thought provoking. It is nerve racking to feel the future responsibility of creating morally good citizens after reading this because of the intensity of Ayers' main claims. But this pressure is necessary and good, as teachers need to understand their importance when it comes to helping each individual student which will in turn create a healthy, functioning society.
ReplyDeleteAyers presents teaching as not just a job but a moral and ethical responsibility. He expresses the choice teachers make of what to teach and how to teach it and how that should reflect inclusiveness while also including ethical implications. He challenges the idea that teaching is neutral or purely technical, instead arguing that teaching is political and driven by value. Teachers, themselves, must actively work toward freedom, justice and equality. With that, classrooms should encourage critical thinking besides only memorization. He shifts the idea of teaching from purely just delivering content (a traditional approach) to shaping engaged, democratic citizens. Ayers pushes teachers to examine themselves as a whole and take on the role of establishing fair and inclusive classrooms based on both their values and beliefs as well as the students'. I really enjoyed reading this chapter.
ReplyDeleteRather than discuss different teaching methods or theories, Ayers’ talks about the purpose of teaching and how our teaching methods can speak volumes about a teacher’s moral and ethical beliefs. Ayers is looking at the enterprise of teaching beyond subjects and curriculum content, instead he encourages teachers to ask “what am I teaching for? And what am I teaching against?” (11). This is an important question I’ve begun thinking about especially in light of my teacher interview that I did over spring break. The teacher I spoke with really emphasized her belief that teaching goes beyond facts and information. She believes she is teaching young people how to be kind, capable, responsible, and creative thinkers in society. Ayers describes this as “help[ing] human beings reach the full measure of their humanity” (1). I also liked that Ayers encourages teachers to create a list of what they are teaching for and against to remind them when they feel lost.
ReplyDeleteI also think the discussion of humanistic and dehumanizing teaching was interesting to read about compared to what we’ve talked about in class related to traditional and progressive teaching styles. This added a new and different layer to these teaching practices for me. A humanistic teaching approach reminds me of progressive education. Students embrace possibility, discovery, curiosity, and the teacher imparts “you can change your life and you must; you can transform your world, if you will” (2). Whereas traditional teaching can be dehumanizing because it teaches students the “denial of the right to question and decide for oneself, to make up one’s own mind” (3) and introduces the idea of teachers as authoritarian figures overseeing a students' passive education. I think adding this layer of moral and ethical interpretation to these teaching practices emphasizes the potential for either a positve or negative influence that teacher's have in their students lives.
Ayers' way of teaching is very progressive and student centered because it encourages teachers to incorporate students into the learning process. Ayers shows that he focuses on critical thinking, creativity, and creating free thinkers rather than things such as standardized tests. Ayer’s sees education as humanistic which means that he wants education to be about the whole person rather than just dumping knowledge into students like vessels. Ayer’s also brings up that education that focuses solely on facts, compliance, and obedience fundamentally strips students of their humanity. Ayer’s was also very influenced by Paulo Freire and believed that eduction is never neutral it is always for something on against something. Ayer’s shows that his way of teaching is aimed towards liberation for students. In the chapter Ayer’s talks about a teacher's role in making moral choices he states that “ a teacher’s job is not to dictate a moral choice or hide behind a manual of decision making, their job is to help students navigate possibilities, analyze context and ultimately help them build the internal fortitude to live with their own consequences. A term Ayer’s uses to describe schools that are rigid and make students conform to their systems is uni-culture. Ayer’s believes that modern schools are migrating towards this type of education, which does not empower students and encourage them to grow.
ReplyDeleteAngel Crawley
DeleteAyers' way of teaching is a lot more than just delivering information to the students. He wants to help the students find their place in society and grow as people. Ayers teaches in a way that encourages curiosity and critical thinking. Something I took away from this chapter was realizing even more how much more teaching is than just a job. It is a responsibility to help students understand what the real world is including relationships, identity, and even justice.
ReplyDeleteI thought Ayers way of thinking about teaching was very informative and inspiring. He introduced a particular concept that said that teachers should think of themselves on the same level as the students, in the way that they are both learning. Students, the curriculum, and teachers, the strengths and weaknesses of the students, in order to formulate their teaching in a way that benefits and suits the needs of the students.
ReplyDeleteIn the reading, he talks about teaching as something deeper than just learning the curriculum and " passing knowledge". He mainly talks about how connecting with the students or a bond helps benefit learning.The idea of being more than a teacher and more of a role modle or guide to a younger audience that may not have found there place or who they want to be is a great idea but the borderline of parenting and teaching can be hard to not cross. Which I think can be difficult to really make or break those certain relationships that could help a child reach their full potential or help them discover certain parts of themselves they may not know is even there. Yet I do like the idea that having deeper realationships with students and caring for them more than just what the school says is important.
ReplyDeleteIn this chapter, Ayers argues against the traditional approach of education, believing that instead of the curriculum focused "by-the-book" orientation, teaching should instead be a guiding light to their students, allowing them to achieve their most productive and social form imaginable. He believes education should focus rather on what valuable information and experiences the teacher can provide for students, as opposed to simply how much course knowledge can be instilled. In this case, Ayers holds a very progressive view of education. He believes that it should not be a rigid structure, and instead that a good teacher must be able to creatively and effectively adapt to any number of circumstances. I agree with Ayers' beliefs that a teacher's role is to establish their students as moral beings, and that the dynamics of a classroom is larger than sole course content.
ReplyDeleteI think Ayers talks about teaching in a way that's different from how we usually think. Most people see it as just giving information, but he shows it can either help students grow or actually hurt them, depending on how it’s done. The part about schools being used for control, especially with indigenous students, really stood out to me.
ReplyDeleteIt made me realize teaching isn’t always a good thing. It can either make students feel respected or make them feel controlled and ignored. Overall, it changed how I look at teaching, especially thinking about my own experience in public school.
This reading looks at teaching as more than just giving students information, about how teachers treat students and the kind of environment they create. Ayers focuses a lot on the difference between teaching that humanizes students and teaching that controls or dehumanizes them. He makes the point that teaching isn’t neutral, it’s always shaped by values, whether that’s encouraging creativity and respect or just enforcing rules and authority. One thing that stood out to me was how he talks about school as one of the first places students experience power and hierarchy, which means teachers have a big impact on how students see fairness and justice. Overall, his way of talking about teaching made it feel more like a moral responsibility than just a job, and it added a new perspective on how much influence teachers really have.
ReplyDeleterobin powers
DeleteAyers believes that teaching is much more than simply passing on knowledge and describes it as both a personal and intellectual act that requires judgment, reflection, and a deep understanding of students’ lives. Rather than being something fully controlled, teaching is an “enterprise” filled with uncertainty, he views as a normal and necessary part of the process, not a flaw. This perspective shifts the idea of teaching from something fixed and predictable to something that must constantly adapt and evolve. He also challenges the belief that there is a single, simple method for effective teaching. Instead, teachers must make decisions in the moment, shaped by their specific circumstances, relationships, and values. Ayers emphasizes that teaching is never neutral; it always reflects beliefs about power and society. Because of this, teaching carries a strong moral and social responsibility, making it both meaningful and demanding, requiring creativity, responsibility, and ongoing reflection.Ayers further argues that schools also attempt to answer larger human questions, such as the meaning of life. For this reason, he stresses the importance of teaching kindness, partnership, and democratic values in the classroom, aligning with the principles of critical pedagogy. This perspective develops a strong moral early on creates a foundation for both education and life. A more progressive approach to teaching can help foster critical thinking from an early age. In contrast, Ayers criticizes traditional teaching methods, even pointing to extreme historical examples like Nazi Germany to illustrate the dangers of authoritarian approaches. He highlights the teacher’s responsibility in what he calls “the task of humanization,” while also acknowledging the risk of the opposite,dehumanization, which he associates with more rigid, traditional models of education. At the same time, he recognizes that teaching through critical pedagogy to develop thoughtful, morally grounded citizens is not easy. It requires constant ethical decision-making, which can often be complex and challenging.
ReplyDeleteAyers talks about teaching being more than delivering content. He treats it as something human and moral, not technical. What stood out to me is how he frames teaching as an “enterprise” full of uncertainty, where teachers are constantly making judgment calls based on real people, not just following a set method. That idea that there is no perfect formula for teaching was new to me and made the role feel more complex and personal .
ReplyDeleteI agree with him here too that teaching cannot be a morally or politically (and in my opinion, even religiously) neutral act. Every decision a teacher makes reflects values about what kind of society we want and the values we want to instill in our students. It is one of the first places students experience authority and develop their sense of justice. Because of that, the way a teacher runs a classroom can either support students as individuals or limit them.
Overall, I think Ayers is trying to move away from the view of teaching as dominating the classroom. Instead, he sees it as helping students grow into thoughtful and independent people. I think my personal call to teaching is a philosophical one. To be good teachers, we must be ever evolving in our philosophy because we apply and practice these ideas in real life.
ReplyDeleteAyers sees the act of teaching as a relationship, a learning experience and an ongoing reflection. This is different from seeing it as simply a task to be accomplished; instead it is about making choices that are ethically grounded, that reflect the political climate in which they are being made and that will shape the lives of students and the world at large. He positions teachers not as all knowing experts but as learners themselves engaged in continuous inquiry with their students. He also sees the individual student as important. Not just as a learner, but as a person whose values, experiences and history are important for the teacher to understand.
I feel Ayers talks about teaching in a way that is more real and simple than most people do. He shows that teaching entails not merely imparting information, but also comprehending students and adapting to their requirements. One thing that struck me is that teaching isn't always easy to figure out, and that's fine. It made me understand that teaching doesn't always have to be perfect or planned out. I also liked what he said about how teaching can change how kids see themselves and the world. In general, his ideas made me realize that teaching requires patience, adaptability, and concern.
ReplyDelete3/18
ReplyDeleteWhen reading this I noticed that the point was to encourage teaching in a way that promotes humanization rather than methods that foster dehumanization. He says that teachers are responsible for teaching in an inclusive way. Public education plays a direct role in how the next generation thinks. It’s important for teachers to strive towards teaching fairness, critical thinking, and justice. Ayers doesn’t believe that teaching is a neutral profession, instead he thinks the job is inherently political and driven by values. I have to agree, many of my history classes changed how history was taught based solely on the teachers political beliefs. I had a leftist civics teacher in middle school, a center left world history teacher in 9th grade and a MAGA republican government teacher senior year. Each class had a bit of overlap but it was vastly different how history and policy were presented. The best history class was one where the personal beliefs of the teacher didn’t affect the class too much but the basic morals did. This is where I got my love of knowledge because the teacher made the class so interesting and it didn’t feel biased, just encouragement to be educated and think critically. It also encouraged our senses of empathy and justice. I believe this is the way to teach, it's about teaching morals. However morals are deemed political and that's why teaching is so politicized.
Ayers talks about how teaching is connected to the society we want to create. He argues that education plays a part a major role in shaping how students think, question and engage. He steers away from the traditional view of teachers solely delivering material and doing as they are told by the curriculum. Ayers also highlights how schools can reinforce inequality, often giving some students more opportunities than others, which makes it important for teachers to be aware of these systems and work towards equity. One thing that stood out to me how he talks about education promoting freedom. He said it should promote freedom by encouraging critical thinking and emphasis on student voice, rather than control and memorization. I think this is important relating to teachers because commonly they are seen and treated as replaceable and "babysitters". Learning about a mindset Ayers argues gives me motivation to become a teacher because we can make a great impact. Overall, the chapter suggests that teachers have responsibility not just to teach content, but to challenge injustice and help students become active ,and thoughtful members in society.
ReplyDeleteAyers talks about how he believes teaching is more than just giving lessons, but how its a reflective practice and more of a human and moral practice as well. He believes that teaching is not just something you master, but you keep learning, questioning, and growing. His perspective on schools has a lot of ideas about student voice, relationships, and social justice. One thing that stood out to me was him talking about how teaching is not just about helping students be successful academically, but also caring, and advocating for them as well. He wants teachers to see their students as people who have a voice, identity, and experiences that matter in the classroom.
ReplyDelete