Monday, January 12, 2026

3/30…Classroom Management/School Discipline and the Aims of Schooling

 What was school discipline like where you went to school? Looking back, can you remember any teachers who did a particularly good job of managing their class? What did they do/not do?

30 comments:

  1. There have been times I have been disciplined at school when I was younger like Elementary. We would have colors that determine your behavior, green was good, yellow was iffy and red was bad. If we were bad we would have to move our color and I think in my opinion it did work since I would always be sad if I had to move a color. Yet I didn't hate my teacher or blame her, she was a good teacher and very kind. She had good communication skills and knew how to talk to younger children about discipline. I feel like when I think back to it there were some teachers would do discipline in the form of rewards and if you didn't do good or do enough you only got two toppings instead of five on your ice cream which In my opinion is not a good way at all to change anyones ways.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In my school, discipline was a very big thing. It helped everyone stay safe. If a student ever hurt someone else, they would be kicked out of school. This emphasis on rules was most evident in a particular teacher’s class. Their class was always well-behaved. It was very rare for a student to get sidetracked. This teacher had a commanding presence. No student dared question this teacher. They did not allow any disrespect and would immediately call a staff member to take a student to the office if they were being too unruly. This teacher made sure their class was a quiet and good place to learn.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In my schools, discipline was always done between the student and the faculty member that either saw what they did or gets to decide what the consequence is going to be. It was only ever made public if it affected the whole school which I only remember happening twice. I have had teachers who ran a strict classroom and others who had no control or care. I think the best, and my favorites, were the ones who had an equal balance. They were very understanding and kind but also had rules and expectations that needed to be met. But again, if there were a problem it would be dealt with privately unless it affected the whole school or the whole class. I liked it because it kept the student accountable while also keeping it out of other people's businesses.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Discipline in my school was pretty traditional. We had lunch detention, in-school suspension, major/minor referrals just like any other public school. Students of color were reprimanded at a disproportionate rate, another common feature of many public high schools. Disciplinary measures changed a lot over my four years because my freshman year was also our principal’s first year. So I think every few months systems would need to be workshopped or reevaluated. By the end of my time, it seemed like all of the discipline was being outsourced to our administrative team. We had one principal and 4 assistant principals. Teachers would fill out a Google Form detailing the issue and the student, then it would alert the administration, and someone would be at the room in the next 15 minutes to pull the student out of class and discuss things with them. This seemed to be a very efficient system and also ensured class time would not be wasted on individual student discipline.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I had teachers of all kinds growing up- some that didn't discipline at all, some that made me feel small by the way that they talked to us, and others that had a massive impact on my childhood because of their ability to manage the classroom. I think it was always very clear which teachers just punished students as a reflection of their own frustration with their job being made harder, which can sometimes be understandable when there are students that are very disruptive and difficult, as a normal human reaction. The best teachers first drilled in their expectations for the class and deeply imbedded these expectations into the daily routine which set the students up for success. When the rules were not followed, there was already a pre-determined consequence. I think the ultimate goal is to perfect balance these boundaries and tight routines with excellent relationships with your students. I heard from a teacher once that she used to talk to previous teachers about her upcoming class and figure out which students were known to be "difficult". On the very first day she would find out what their hobbies/extracurriculars were, and then find ways to show up for those students outside of the classroom like attending their sports games. She said this always worked for the "difficult" kids who are often mindlessly nagged by adults which causes them to check out/act out more. These kids are often young boys in sports and I think we are so quick to label them as "troubled" and "to be dealt with" which often reinforces bad behavior and they aren't incentivised to do better for teachers who don't like them. I think most of the time, these kids don't feel called in by the adults around them. Kids really want to be cared about by their teachers, outside of the context of academic performance because I think they sense that there is more meaning to school than academic performance and we need to hold up our end of the deal to give these kids a reason to try hard for.

    ReplyDelete
  6. From what I remember, discipline in my school was average. In elementary school I remember having behavior charts, a reward system, class rewards/goals, and being sent to the principals office for anything serious. In middle school, my school had in-school suspension, lunch suspension (which was just sitting in a small room away from everyone else), and we also could be excluded from "fun Fridays". High School was just detention and security. I remember in elementary school most of my teachers were good at managing the classes, I didn't have a teacher who wasn't in control. In high school though it depended if students liked you. The "cool" teachers still had good class management.

    ReplyDelete
  7. School discipline where I went was kind of a mix ome teachers were really strict, while others were more relaxed and just expected you to act right. Most of the time, if you got in trouble it meant a warning first, then maybe detention if you kept messing up. There were definitely a few classes where things got loud if the teacher didn’t really have control. One teacher I remember who was really good at managing the class never had to yell. They set the tone from the first day, made the rules clear, and stuck to them. What stood out was how calm they stayed even when people were being annoying, they didn’t lose their temper. They’d just pause, look at you, or say something quietly, and it worked. It made it feel like they were in control without being mean.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In elementary school I was in a class with one kid who would have temper tantrums. My teacher would acknowledge their problem but then move on with the class. I always thought this was interesting when I was younger because I expected them to get in trouble for being a disruption. Really though, in situations like this, these are just emotions expressed at maybe not the best time but that isn't something all little kids understand yet. Obviously if the situation escalates, the teacher or some adult should privately help this kid and take them away from the class but overall, punishing this behavior will most likely result in more anger. It makes me think of the podcast episode I listened to that described part of the teacher's job as being a detective and not just assuming kids are trying to cause trouble. It is cool to look back at my old class and realize my teacher was helping this kid by letting them feel their feelings instead of using discipline to try and suppress them.

    ReplyDelete
  9. When I was in school discipline was in simple ways that you see in the more traditional setting. The teacher would start with either telling you to be quiet and go back to your seat, or make you move if the people around you were getting distracted. If the issue was bigger, you would get lunch detention, or after school detention. If it was a very serious issue, you could get in school suspension, out of school suspension, or even expelled. Throughout my time in school I had teachers who were very lenient because they did not want to get on there students bad side so they would avoid getting them in trouble, but I also had teaches who were very strict and took discipline very seriously.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I feel like I saw the most i experienced school discipline was in k-5. I feel as we get older we recognize the expectations for our classes and the discipline almost kind of disappears in a way. I would say most of my K-5 teachers had a behavior chart. You would start at green, if you were being “bad” you would move down to yellow, and if it continued you moved down to green. I have also seen positive reinforcements for doing a good job. When i was younger this really worked for me. I had some teachers reward students with a sticker or a piece of candy for doing a job. I would end up putting more of an effort into my work so that I can have that stick or piece of candy. Honestly either of their methods could be bad, but everyone is different. What worked for me may have not worked for someone else, but it was nice to have a mix of both of these methods in with some teachers.

    ReplyDelete
  11. When I was younger, my elementary school definitely disciplined other students and me. Of course, you had the normal name clips that would be moved from different colors, like green, orange, yellow, and red, to indicate how close you were to a punishment, like a parent phone call. They would also have you walk around the playground instead of actually being able to participate in recess. You would just have to watch your friends play as you completed however many laps you had to do until you were able to join them. I think my teachers who chose these forms of discipline did do a good job of managing their classroom because it focused on the individual and not the entire class as a whole.

    ReplyDelete
  12. In my experience throughout elementary, middle, and high school, my teachers didn’t hesitate to discipline my peers, and I. They were quite a few teachers who would lecture us alone in front of other students, which could be quite embarrassing. There was always detention, but the reason for you went became less strict, as I grew older. Once, in elementary school, I got detention for telling a kid that I didn’t like him. Whereas, in high school, I never had detention, as I didn’t break any school code. I found that the teachers who lectured me privately left a much more positive effect on my mind, rather than the teachers who would publicly embarrass me.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Throughout my elementary school, I remember having the color chart and the red would be a call home or sent to the principals office. Most middle school, the teacher would either separate and embarrass students from the rest of the class or send students to the prinicpals office, although there were warnings beforehand, and high school was warning and being sent to the office. As I remember some did not do a good job at managing the class which is why students were sent to the office because I do remember some not giving warning or pulling the student aside to explain why they are getting in trouble and such.

    ReplyDelete
  14. For examples that I can recall in terms of discipline, I remember having the behaviour chart with clips of our names back in 5th grade, that same teacher also had a reward jar whereby participating or being a good student you could get your name in the jar for a loterry of chair pillows every week.
    In highschool there was a lot of cheating in tats and such, but they never did anything to said kids other than in and after school detention.

    ReplyDelete
  15. My high school had an Honor and Judicial council that had students on it and teacher sponsors. If a student cheated on a paper or test or broke some other school they went in front of the student council and had a ‘hearing’ where the students could then recommend what the punishment should be to the teacher. I always thought this was an interesting program because it was supposed to be very secretive, but always one way or another gossip spread about you having been seen by the Honor council and what they did. Additionally the teachers didn’t have to follow through with the student recommended punishment, so in some situations the student council was a little pointless.
    Honestly at my school, good behavior was expected from the get go, so most of my classes didn’t really need strict classroom management because everyone was well behaved and if you weren’t, frankly, you were expelled. In elementary school, I remember a lot of calls and responses or clapping patterns to get the class's attention. Like, “1,2,3 eyes on me” and the students would respond, “1,2 eyes on you.” Another strategy, which looking back is kind of funny and passive aggressive, was I had teachers who would sit quietly at the front of the room, arms crossed, and they would say “I can wait.” When this happened you just knew it was time to settle down.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Most of elementary followed a conduct card system where a teacher would fill a report every week on how each student behaves in class. I remember this one 3rd grade teacher frequently making phone calls to my mom for getting into a lot of trouble, which reached to a point where my mom asked her to stop calling because she was busy at work. Many of my high school teachers did a great job telling me straight up if I'm disruptive. None of them really sent me to detention or penalized me with referrals, they'd tell me to be quiet in front of the entire class room and it usually shut me right up.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Emma Lucius-MillimanMarch 31, 2026 at 10:03 AM

    In elementary school in my old school system the discipline varied from school to school. In middle school there was barely any disciple and high school they just took the kid out of the classroom. From what I saw they school and teachers only did as much as the budget would allow. I didn't have any teachers that really stuck out to me, they all had similar discipline styles. However, it felt like some of the teachers had given up by the time I left high school.

    ReplyDelete
  18. The school I went to didn't have much discipline. You could see most people walking around the halls and fighting. There was rarely anything done about it, I mean, maybe detention for a fight, but most of the time, there was no action taken. It got stricter over the years. We were supposed to put our phones in a pocket in the front of the class, but usually the teacher wouldn't make us. One teacher I had followed every rule, though. Late to class- tardy, phone out - Taken to the office, bathroom - one person at a time. I always thought that was so strict, but honestly, in the school I was in, that needed to happen. So, I feel that if most teachers were like that, the school wouldn't have been as bad as it was.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Discipline in my schools was always fairly traditional--we usually had the red, yellow, and green boxes with our names in elementary school, lunch detention in middle school, and in-school suspension and out-of-school suspension in high school, with each level also having referrals. There was one teacher, though, who I remember distinctly for his disciplinary approach. In fourth grade, we were introduced to these things called Pink Slips. They were disciplinary notes that acted essentially as miniature referrals; while one simply acted as a strike, multiple would lead to higher levels of punishment. That fourth grade math and science teacher was not at all afraid to pass these out. I was never a bad student, and so I never got a pink slip, but I remember the kids at my table discussing the amount of slips they had been given. It's been a decade, but I want to say one of them noted they had around thirty-five. Similarly, those same two kids had gotten in trouble for something, and thus we were *all* assigned upper-level textbook equations, despite the rest of us not doing anything wrong. Safe to say, I know that many of us in that class did not appreciate his strictness.

    ReplyDelete
  20. As far as I can remember, in elementary school we had behavior charts which kept a lot of kids in check because we would be rewired if we stayed on green for the whole week. In high school and middle school there was some discipline but it really just depended on the teacher. There were some teachers who would people get away just about anything and there were some who would punish kids over nothing. There was a lot of lunch detention and in school suspension. I only knew a few kids who go out of school suspension. That usually only happened when there were drugs involved or physical altercations.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Discipline was fairly inconsistent at the schools I went to. Student behavior and punishment for it was typically determined by individual teachers who would not compare notes with one another, and any school-wide threats made by administration were not usually followed through on or significantly reduced in scale.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I feel like discipline at my school was extremely random and inconsistent. Punishments were never equal or made sense, and the people who got punished was completely randomized as well. Some people got away with anything, some people made one little mistake and got completely messed up by it. The teachers I remember succeeding at managing their class was the ones I felt acted the most like normal real people. The teachers that knew respect went both ways and not just one managed to keep classes pretty well in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  23. In my experience, school discipline really depended on the grade. In high school, it felt pretty inconsistent—different teachers had totally different rules, and sometimes they reacted differently depending on the student. It didn’t always feel fair or predictable. In elementary school, it was more structured with the color system: green meant you were doing well, yellow was a warning, and red meant your parents were getting called. It was clear, but also an announcement to the whole class about how you treated school/the teacher since everyone could see it.
    The teachers who handled their classes best were the ones who were consistent and fair with everyone. They made their expectations clear and stuck to them. They stayed calm, didn’t call students out in a harsh way, and actually treated people with respect. They didn’t play favorites or overreact, which made the classroom feel more comfortable.

    ReplyDelete
  24. When I was in elementary school, I was very poorly behaved to be quite honest. I faced a lot of different punishments, but they were mostly one or a combination of these: getting sent to the principals office, call/email home to parents, getting sent to sit in another classroom, etc. These were all pretty ineffective and only made elementary school Calvin more upset. In high school, I did not have this issue anymore. I noticed that my teachers who had the best control over their classrooms were the ones who ruled with a gentle hand, but they did not budge on certain things, most notably phones, being rude/disrespectful, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  25. For about a good portion of my life, I was living in New York so going to school there was not a small and sort of "communal thing." There were a LOT of students in just about most of the schools in the city; I want to say like around 2000+ students in each of the middle schools as well as the high schools. I wouldn't say I was the easiest kid to deal with in class, so I can kind of speak up for some of the teachers in those schools who had to discipline the kids because not all of them are all uppity and goody. A lot of the students would talk loudy, used technology in class and would say some inappropriate things in class that would disturb other students. I feel like the way that they took care of the bad students by like being strict but careful was a good strategy to keep the students on the right track while also teaching them a lesson.

    ReplyDelete

  26. Where I went to school discipline was always enforced. Mainly in my elementary school for classroom discipline, we would have colors that reflected how our behavior was for the day, and if you were on red at the end of the day, you would get a call home. In my elementary and middle school we would do silent lunch for just an individual person or the whole class. During silent lunch we could not talk until the end of lunch; this was also usually followed by no recess when I was in elementary school. In my middle school most disciplinary actions would involve an email home if you were doing something disruptive in a certain class or school suspension for harsher punishments. A teacher that I've had that did a good job managing a classroom was my second-grade teacher, Ms. Ray. Ms. Ray was really nice and fair. Part of Ms. Ray's discipline involved talking to her at her desk about how to fix our behavior, or we would be put on silent reflection and reflect on our actions. Ms. Ray would also do class meetings if she felt like we needed to work on things so that everyone could be on the same page.

    ReplyDelete
  27. The rules at my school were pretty strict. Most of the time, it was about not breaking the rules and staying out of trouble, like being quiet, turning in work on time, and being nice to the teacher. If you didn't, you would usually get a warning, detention, or be kicked out of class. It seemed more about controlling students than really figuring out why they were acting the way they were. I do remember a few teachers who did a good job of running their classrooms when I think back. The main thing they did differently was get to know their students. They talked to us like we were humans with feelings not just students, and it was clear they cared. That made us respect them more and not want to act out in their class.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I didn’t have much personal experience with discipline in my k-12 schooling, but looking back at it there I can see both the good and bad in how discipline was handled in my schools. Retrospectively the best teachers were the ones who gave everyone a clean slate at the beginning of the year. Many of the “bad” students were never given second chances and it seemed that labeling them as a “bad kid” limited them to that. I think that was pretty bad classroom management and everyone should get a fresh start to improve themselves.

    ReplyDelete

3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)

  What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...