What is critical pedagogy and what you do think of it? What connections can you make between the idea of critical pedagogy and the Gutierrez article?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
-
React to this film. One possible topic is to relate this film to the recent CRT controversy.
Critical pedagogy places students and teachers as equals and emphasizes that they can both learn from each other. Instead of students passively listening to teachers' lectures, Paulo Freire believed that "equal footing, solidarity, and mutual respect", which come from students and teachers as equals within a classroom, can lead to positive dialogue, which he considers is crucial to critical pedagogy. I really like this idea of education, and when I think back on some of my favorite classes in high school or college so far, they followed this theory. These classes provided lots of opportunities for reflection, questioning, and engaging in conversation with the teacher and other students.
ReplyDeleteIn Gutierrez’s article, one of the things she talks about is how test scores aren’t accurate representations of whether a student is learning or not. I think Freire would agree with this. A lot of test prep teaching follows the “banking” model of education and doesn’t encourage students to critically think about and reflect on why they are learning something. Instead, the focus is on one’s ability to memorize information, and, as Gutierrez points out, this is a “distractor, keeping us from addressing gaps in actual learning.”
Critical pedagogy is an educational philosophy that promotes critical thinking from the student's point of view regarding inequalities and power structures, rather than just accepting the facts. I believe this is an important way to learn because it ties what we learn to the world outside the classroom and promotes critical thinking and action. This concept, as it is used in the Gutierrez article, ties into the concept of culturally relevant instruction, valuing the student's background and experience in the classroom.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is an approach to teaching that promotes social justice, critical thinking, and empowerment among students. I think critical pedagogy is powerful and necessary in education as it respects students as thinkers and puts higher meaning to education. Students are pushed to higher thinking rather than just memorizing certain facts. In Gutierrez's article she emphasizes the achievement gap mentioning that test scores, income and family background do not accurately gage one's education and their readiness to learn. Rather than focusing on what students lack she highlights what each student brings. Critical pedagogy values student's identities and encourages multiple approaches to learning, therefore I think it is all the more necessary and important to be in practice in a school setting.
ReplyDeleteI think critical pedagogy is a reasonable solution to what Gutierrez criticizes in her writing about the education system. The power structures that philosopher Paulo Freire encourages students and teachers to challenge is what creates and allows processes like standardized testing to play a major role in determining how well a student is doing. I agree with Gutierrez that whether or not a student is succeeding in school is way more complicated than a score. A grade cannot represent how someone learns, what their personal skills are and what external factors are affecting them and I like how Gutierrez emphasizes by saying it's wrong to compare students based on test scores. Overall, critical pedagogy and its focus surrounding student empowerment and learning about topics that make such an impact on our world, like racism, justice, feminism, etc., are going to be more effective than the traditional learning approach that frames success around how many facts can be memorized in order to pass a test.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is an approach that helps students with critical thinking, and to get them more involved in the classroom. Students are encouraged to speak up and share their thoughts and opinions and to have an active role in learning. Its valuable to learning because students get to express themselves and they get to feel seen and heard. It also requires teachers to respect their students and their students thoughts and opinions. Connections I can make to Gutierrez article and critical pedagogy is that they both focus on the idea of students having a voice. They both express the importance of valuing students and their backgrounds and cultures.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy sets a precedent that the teacher and the student are at equal with one another, as opposed to the traditional hierarchical structure in which the teacher is above their pupils. It seeks to educate on the grounds of critical awareness; that being, informing students of the social injustices and contradictions found in their day to day life and seeking to take action against it. This experimental and philosophical form of teaching allows not only for the students to benefit from the wisdom of the teacher, but, because they are placed on equal footing, the teacher can benefit from the wisdom of their students. This sounds especially savory to me, as I have always treated my future in education as a bargain of knowledge between myself and my students.
ReplyDeleteThis form of education ties nicely into Gutierrez's article, as she finds that the traditional model of education disadvantages minority students. She believes in expanding education to be more than a one-size-fits-all approach to such a diverse cast of students.
Critical pedagogy in teaching is concerned with power, inequalities and social justice. It is not focused on the transfer of information or facts from teacher to learner; rather than an approach to teaching/learning as a collective and political process.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is effective in many ways because it acknowledges and respects students' thinking processes and their individual experiences (especially those students who belong to the historically marginalized groups) rather than labeling students as being unable to achieve well. The process of critical pedagogy looks at how schools and the educational system are structured, instead of asking the question of why students cannot achieve well due to their own lack of academic ability or personal characteristics. However, one of the main barriers to implementing critical pedagogy in many school districts across the United States is the fact that most school districts have become extremely accountable-based. Accountability has come into the form of state-wide, district-wide, and school-wide assessment accountability measures which cause most educators to be forced to teach within a very structured curriculum framework that does not allow them much flexibility. Many teachers are now being forced to teach to the standards of the assessments, therefore they do not have enough time to think critically about the curriculum they are teaching.
DeleteGutierrez talks in her article “Improving Education and the Mistaken Focus on Raising Test Scores and Closing the Achievement Gap,” there are flaws in the policies of education today. The current focus on raising test scores and closing the achievement gap are attempts to fix problems without addressing the underlying problems in education.
Recently I have been so taken with Pedagogy of the Oppressed; it kind of feels like my bible. Critical Pedagogy is a model that prioritizes a democratic relationship between student and teacher. Freire aims to transform the “banking method of education” where students are the receptacles of knowledge bestowed by their instructors to a “problem-posing education” in which students and teachers together will gain conscientização, or in English, critical consciousness. Conscientização is the emergence from a submersion, it's the ability for a person to observe their “situationality”, reflect upon it, then intervene and change it! Freire (and thinkers that precede him) says that the ultimate goal of every person is to increase their humanity. To me this sentiment links to the Gutiérrez article in many ways. The process of preparing for a standardized test that Gutierrez narrates in the second paragraph seems pretty dehumanizing to me; it is taking each unique student and reducing them to a numerical metric and then worse, plaster them to graphs and data analysis comparing them to the previous years nameless list of scores. It dehumanizes teachers too in a way. Nobody becomes a teacher so they can stand in front of a room and teach for the test. It strips teachers of their agency—or at leasts diverts most of their energy into making sure their students will secure passing test scores instead of cultivating a rich environment that prioritizes dialogue, consciousness, and intentionality, as outlined in Chapter 3 of Freire's book.
ReplyDeleteFrom the videos, I learned that critical pedology is a form of teaching that breaks the norms of the hierarchy in education. Freire created this unique form of teaching that benefits the student and the teacher. Students are commonly faced with a set of rules, deadlines, and rubrics they must follow and they are restricted from creative flow on their own. Critical pedology states that the students have a say in their learning and their learning can be socially constructed. By taking away the structure of the teacher having all the power to run the classroom however and the student can't do anything, students gain motivation to learn and work with the teachers. I think this should be taught to everyone because it can be implemented in more than just a classroom.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a teaching method that helps students with critical thinking and topics of social justice by removing their social status as a student and letting them express their opinions as citizens of their environment. I think that this method of learning is definitely helpful in raising students to be democratic participants of society.
ReplyDeleteThe connection that can be made with the article is the idea that students are people first, the idea in education is that we are increasing their knowledge, helping raise their knowledge floor, not trying to make them reach a pre-determined level cap. It's this idea that education should be based on the student themself, not previous students, and not some statistically calculated data.
Critical pedagogy is the philosophy that teachers and students should challenge the standard social hierarchy in education with teachers above students. The philosophy promotes the active change of education from a "banking" system of passive knowledge process that fosters "conscientizacao" (critical consciousness). It is the promotion of collective thinking and learning by analyzing and challenging inequalities (such as racism, sexism, and poverty). Critical pedagogy is valuable because it helps students see how education connects to their lives, identities, and communities. It promotes critical thinking skills that go beyond school and prepare students to engage thoughtfully with society.Gutiérrez emphasizes the importance of students’ cultural, linguistic, and social backgrounds in the learning process. This aligns with critical pedagogy’s focus on valuing students’ lived experiences as legitimate sources of knowledge.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is an approach to education that encourages students to think critically about how social forces and power shape what is taught and how learning is measured. Gutierrez’s article reflects this perspective by arguing that an intense focus on standardized testing and the achievement gap can distract from broader questions of equity in education. Truthfully, I really believe in the power of a quality traditional education and I think holding students to high standards can bring so much confidence and purpose to students. I think there are limits to how far we should take any educational philosophy, of course. Public schools often leaves people with a bad taste in their mouths for traditional education, rightfully, because many teachers don't fully think through what they believe or why they believe it. This leads to a pre-packaged "traditional" education. Would you feel the same way about traditional education if you had left highschool with a mastery of literature, science, and even high level ability to paint, play a sport, etc? I think students are capable of so much more than we offer them credit for which is why our public school systems fall short of preparing students for adulthood and college level academics. I do believe that there is absolutely a place for critical pedagogy. In my view, probably after students have built the foundation of a traditional education, in higher level classes because I think that prepares them with a sense of responsibility to learn as well, that I think is needed for a more student centered curriculum.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is kind of like teaching in a way that motivates students to question what's going on in the world around them instead of just memorizing what's in their textbook. I like it because it gives students a totally different way to show their creativeness and intelligence to make learning feel more meaningful.. especially for students who don’t always feel like they know what their doing in school. This wraps in with the gutierrez article because she also talks about valuing students so both focus on making education more inclusive and connected to real life.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a type of teaching that encourages students and teachers to challenge the traditional classroom power structure/social hierarchy , where teachers are seen as the only source of knowledge and students are below teachers. Instead of students passively receiving information, critical pedagogy encourages critical thinking and awareness of social issues like racism, sexism, and poverty. It helps students connect what they learn in school to their own lives, identities, and communities. Gutiérrez emphasizes the importance of students’ cultural, language, and social backgrounds, which supports the idea that students’ experiences are valuable sources of knowledge. Critical pedagogy also views teachers and students as equals who learn from each other. Paulo Freire believed that mutual respect and open dialogue between teachers and students lead to better learning. This idea of education stands out to me because some of my favorite classes encouraged discussion, reflection, and active participation.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is an educational philosophy centered around social justice, and it aims to empower students to analyze and challenge power structures, inequity, and oppression. I think this concept is great, as it provides a progressive approach to a system that has done many wrong, and continues to. Gutiérrez, in her article, claims that testing and test scores are not a good method of judging a students skills or intellect. Testing is an outdated part of the system that favors the neurotypical, and a philosophical and progressive solution to this is revamping how we determine students' progress.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a philosophy used in teaching that aims to help students be equal to or in power when it comes to learning. Instead of just the normal standard learning, it helps students use thier critical consciousness. It also helps students use problem solving tatcis and use that in real world scenario isntead of learning things they may not use in the future or real world. In the article , the claim is that normal testing and scores aren't good for students since everyone is different and learns different. She wants to use new methods of learnng and apply it to the students to measure the new method and the students intelligence with it, or the outcome.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a way of teaching where students and teachers learn together, ask questions, and talk about real-world issues instead of just memorizing facts. It focuses on helping students think more deeply about fairness, inequality, and what’s happening in society. I think this approach is better because it makes learning more interesting and gives students a chance to share their ideas. This connects to the Gutierrez article because it explains that test scores don’t always show real learning, and instead students learn more when they are able to discuss, question, and understand the material.
ReplyDeleteKayleigh M
DeleteCritical pedagogy is a type of learning where everyone learns something. The teachers and students both learn together. Teachers and students are able to have in-depth conversations about things that involve the real world. This is not something you’d be able to learn by just reading a textbook or listening to lecture in class. Critical pedagogy involves bouncing ideas off one another. This type of teaching encourages students to observe the world around them and form their own opinions. This relates to the Gutierrez article when it talks about test scores. Just because a student can get an A on a test doesn’t mean they actually absorbed the information they we taught. Instead, students should put show their knowledge by implementing it into the real world through hands-on projects, or something similar.
ReplyDeleteCritical Pedagogy is a more student-centered teaching approach, in which students mostly think of their own ways to learn many different subjects as well as topics. Like the students more like communicate with themselves in order to pass along information to each other to help each other succeed in class. It also helps reinforce classmates on social and community issues and how they could combat that, by sort of sticking together and making projects about social movement, or participating in protests, etc. Gutierrez sort of ties into this, as she makes very strong points about trying to make connections to the backgrounds of all her students to process their past experiences and apply them to her class. She also has very strong opinions about test-taking, and she dislikes the whole system. She thinks that he sort of ruins the student's mind by making them think they need to remember and use their brain to gain pointless knowledge only specifically to do the test instead suceeding in the class overall.
ReplyDeleteCaron Robinson
DeleteCritical pedagogy is a teaching method that allows students to question and examine the structures of education. Critical pedagogy was founded by Paul Freire. This philosophy encourages students to use their critical thinking and problem-solving skills. This helps students to bring a change to education and fosters them to create a democratic society. Some key elements of critical pedagogy are democracy, social justice, and problem solving. Gutiérrez promotes critical pedagogy by encouraging the transformation of education by incorporating sociocultural theory and equity in schools.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a teaching philosophy that asserts that teaching should be used to raise critical consciousness among students/learners. This would mean that teachers teach students the "why" and "how" of events, instead of just the "what" and "when" as well as (correctly) teaching history as a dialectical process instead of just a series of random events. This relates to the article by Gutierrez because he advocates for restructuring the education system to teach critical sociological theories in schools.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a concept based on a teacher and their students both being placed on the same level. They both learn from each other. It’s not just a teacher depositing information into their students but the students are instead engaged in what they're learning and everyone's very intentional in the things they do in the classroom. Paulo Freire believed in "equal footing, solidarity, and mutual respect" which is facilitated by ongoing positive dialogue in a classroom where students and teachers are seen as equals. In the Gutierrez article they talk about how tests aren't a good way of telling how much/if the student is learning. I definitely agree with this because tests are often just information recall and there are better ways of testing a student's knowledge. I also think Freire would agree with this because tests stem from power structures which are what he believes schools should challenge.
ReplyDeleteCritical pedagogy is a teaching concept that emphasises social and mental wellbeing by not having a hierarchy. It's the idea that the teacher and student both having things to teach and learn. This is supposed to help critical thinking instead of just learning knowledge. Gutierrez talks about how tests is not the best way to show if a student is learning. I agree with Gutierrez. I was one of the kids that would do really well on homework and then completely bomb the test. Testing can be really stressful for students which means that they cannot perform at there regular learning level. Critical pedagogy was fathered by Paulo Freire, i believe that he would agree with Gutierrez. Tests are designed to keep students in check would would not correlate with the teachings of critical pedagogy.
ReplyDeleteEmma Lucius-Milliman
DeleteCritical pedagogy is a student-centered educational philosophy founded by Paulo Freire that views teaching as political and social, rather than a simple "banking system" of depositing information into students. It highlights helping students become aware of the world around them, and involving their lives in their learning. Gutierrez builds on critical pedagogy and looks at power dynamics in the classroom, emphasizing the importance of a hybrid learning environment to encourage students to challenge dominant social structure. I think critical pedagogy is incredibly important to be incorporating in schools, now more than ever. Its important for students to be aware of what is going on in the world and realize that they have the power to shape the world and their future as they want.
ReplyDelete