Monday, January 12, 2026

2/23…Podcast: Have You Heard? (originally due 2/18)

Post an opinion about something you heard and a question about something you didn’t understand or that you’d like to know more about. Alternatively, you could consider the question of whether/why P-12 teachers might benefit from listening to this podcast.

26 comments:

  1. A question I have is how will K-12 teachers be able to learn about new policies with so much on their plate in a way that does not add more to their workload? Is there an efficient way or reliable source for teachers to get information in order to stay current but avoid being overwhelmed?

    I believe K-12 teachers would benefit by listening to Have You Heard?, as it links large scale educational policy-making decisions with every day K-12 teaching realities. Teachers are able to have a greater understanding of the forces at play in what they do.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I want to learn more about how teachers will put the things they've learned into action. Will there be consequences for teachers if they "overstep" and speak out about things they think are important? Teachers will benefit from listening to Have You Heard?, because a lot of teachers probably feel alone in their struggles in the classroom and school, and listening to this podcast will show them there are people who feel the same. They will get support from other teachers and feel validated in their feelings and opinions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In the podcast, I was particularly interested in the point that the speaker made about schools not only educating children but also imparting cultural values to them. The point that was made about curriculum choices being a reflection of power and societal values was also very striking. I agreed with the point that was made about what we choose to include or exclude in education being a reflection of what we value. However, this point also made me wonder about how critical perspectives can be imparted to children without offending parents and policymakers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I watched Episode 212 - "We're at each other's throats. Schools can help.", and I wholeheartedly agree with the notion that teachers need to serve as role models for their students. A situation in which a teacher builds and maintains interpersonal relationships with their students is completely beneficial for every party involved. The teachers are provided vast, vast amounts of diverse worldviews and value systems, which helps to combat biases and subconscious beliefs. Meanwhile, the students are provided a role model--which is, in some cases, the only role model (or, at least, one of few) in that child's life; though, regardless, each student can benefit from building social skills and nuance which helps break this barrier many build up against oppositional views. This is also why it is essential that we not let AI leech into a teacher's role at large, as it only seeks to hurt any relationship that can be built between teacher and student. While AI is extremely efficient, and can grade and relay course contents at a breeze, it fails to provide students with any meaningful social experience, which hurts them long term. This is also why I fundamentally disagree with the notion mentioned in the podcast, where AI can replace a teacher's duty of grading. I myself have had experiences in the past of building a closer connection to my teacher through comments and whatnot written on my worksheets, which just can't be experienced through the usage of AI. I believe that it is imperative to keep AI out of any learning environments to promote nuance and care between students and teachers and help deconstruct rigid mindsets that would otherwise be reinforced through a machine.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Podcast episode #168 Coming to America featured three different teachers who are progressive/critical in their approach to teaching their immigrant student populations. These classrooms are keen on action civics and the political right often interprets this as training students to be marxist/social change agents (in the words of the male co-host). He attributes this misjudgment to a lack of historical education and context that immigration was largely unrestricted for most of America’s early history which is an important point and something I want to learn a bit more about. How can we restructure misconceptions about immigration and remind people what immigration has looked like in our country’s brief history. He also says of immigrant education that "Ideally students would leave filled up with knowledge AND transformed in a way that actually makes them feel for instance “more American” without having been wiped clean of however they came in feeling at the beginning of their schooling experiences.” He says it in a weird way, but he just means that immigrant K-12 education should make kids feel less isolated, more represented, and thus “more American” which is often the goal for young immigrant students trying to assimilate and balance their different identities. This new vision makes it so students receive a well-rounded education without shifting focus away from their cultural identities.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Episode 155 "Teachers Speak Out" features three teachers who were teacher of the year for different years, and they all received the award because they spoke up for teachers in their states. There are various topics teachers are speaking up for and fighting for what is right. This episode talks about teachers who come together to fight for teaching critical pedagogy in their classrooms. Teachers are silenced when it comes to teaching cultural differences. The teachers featured gave their students a voice in the classroom and allowed their students to form their own opinions without being told how to think. The board wanted to ban this because it isn't part of the curriculum, so it is considered wrong according to the county. The teachers featured on this episode of the podcast disagreed and came together to speak up for their students and all the teachers who were scared to speak up. As someone who has trouble speaking up, I admire the courage these teachers have. They are doing something other teachers should not be scared of and should be able to do with their free will. It is inspiring because the education system deserves to be fought for. The kids deserve to get an education tailored to them and their cultural differences. Teachers shouldn't be confined to teaching just by the book.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have episode #211 Silicon Valley. Maybe I've missed it during the two times I've been listening to the episode, but I just haven't heard any examples as to how AI has been having 'sputnik moments' in education. The guess speaker explains how the vision was a 1984 view of schooling, machine doing the teaching while the teacher reviews the data. I agree that this concept of education is inhuman, dystopian, and that we have application that do this kind of automated and student-specific difficulty adjusting already but not as a primary tool. Maybe I'm misunderstanding the point but the technology that they describe is here already, but I don't think any of my teachers have been replaced, or necessarily sent to the back of their jobs because of these applications, its been more of an additive tool that's used like once a month? Even then the inclusion of AI just seems like clickbait as well, none of these application were AI, just machine learning.
    I mean otherwise the speaker has a great point about our view of education being outdated, that stem shouldn't be the only focus of schools, students shouldn't be seen as numbers, we need to care more about public schools, teachers should be the primary teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Episode 186- This episode was really interesting to me because I am all for limiting or abolishing standardized testing as I believe it truly can't judge one's understanding, readiness or ability to be successful. I have never heard of Massachusetts high school exit exam and I find it kind of insane. They are countering student's diplomas with a test score. I mean that is pretty crazy. I have always thought that standardized testing was a waste because I can understand the content but still be a bad test taker and that will define me all throughout my whole school experience. In no way do I believe that these tests prepare me or see if I am ready for a job after school. This podcast episode brought up a lot of interesting points with comparing what schools were like, what they are like now and what they could be like. I also think that the reason for high school can be different for anyone as it is all about what they are trying to get out of it. If you are just going to high school to get your diploma I think you are missing the whole point. With a variety of different reasons for high school I think schools themselves can't define it for the students, however the students should define it for themselves.

    A question I have based on this podcast is, what can be/ are teacher's role in standardized testing being a qualification to a student's success? Is there a lope-hole they can find to pass the student, like the podcast was mentioning, or are they stuck within the system too?

    ReplyDelete
  9. In the episode “The opposite of Privatization is Publicization” I was able to understand that public schools are becoming more private and a way to fix that is publicizing schools. Publicization involves making private aspects of education and making it accessible to all students and families. This includes accountability, equity, and governance. Something that stood out to me while listening was a part about if the cost of housing is high in a school district that gets access to good funding this could be considered Privatization because only people who can afford to live in that area can go to schools in that district. I also found it interesting that Publicization involves everyone's voice being represented, which is a governance aspect of Publicization . One thing that I would like to know more about is how testing involves accountability in Publicization?

    ReplyDelete
  10. I thought the discussion about Massachusetts using the MCAS as a de facto exit exam showed how “high standards” can sound fair in theory but still hit marginalized students hardest in practice. I’d like to know what alternative statewide system could replace an exit exam while still keeping expectations consistent across districts. I think P–12 teachers could benefit from this podcast because it puts today’s testing debates in historical context and explains why the same accountability arguments keep repeating.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I had episode 155 Teachers speak out, where three teachers of the year share their experiences speaking out for teachers in their states. They talk about why it's important to speak out and how they incorporate critical pedagogy into their classrooms to give students a voice and allow them to form their own opinions. The school board was trying to shut this down because it was not part of the curriculum, but the teachers stood together for their students and others who were afraid to speak out. I liked listening to this podcast because I also like to speak out. It was great to see teachers speaking out to make a difference in the world and teaching in a way that connects to the students world not just the textbook. One thing I would like to learn more about is how the teachers took that step to go to the school board.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I listened to episode #168 - Coming to America which discussed three different school's approaches to helping immigrant and refugee students, and the idea of “Americanizing” immigrants. I thought it was interesting to hear there were two different approaches about how to best support these students. I think this would be beneficial for P-12 teachers to listen to because it addresses common rhetoric used to describe immigrant/refugee students and turns it on it’s head. For example, calling students “English as a Second Language Learners” or “English Learners” is inherently negative, and one of the guests explained it “focuses us on the deficit or what our students have not yet mastered [instead of] focusing on all those strengths they have.” When schools can become more welcoming, supportive, and helpful for newcomer students instead of isolating them, it is beneficial to the whole school community and allows it to become more vibrant.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I listened to the episode were at eachother throats scool can help that and I did agree with a lot of what the podcast people were saying. Especially when it came to how to disagree in a hostile learning manner wether than to disagree and not be in favor with eachother anymore. I like how they say teachers should be helping students learn more than just what is being taught but more like a second cousin or distant relitave. I feel like some paretns do not do that and so teachers become some sort of role model to students. Why it is so important for teachers to not just read off a slide or put on a youtube video and have that type of connection that acually breaks through.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I listened to the podcast "coming to America", and one thing that really stuck with me was listening to them talk about how they feel immigrant students should be taught in schools. They informed us that immigrant students are treated and educated better today then they were back then. They explained that in earlier days immigrants were taught mostly about being American, and forced to give up their language and culture to learn english. Obviously its not perfect yet, but in more modern days our immigrant population is very large and diverse, and educators are more aware how important a students culture is to them.

    ReplyDelete
  15. #211 Silicon Valley’s Vision for Schools is Trapped in a Cold War Fantasy. This episode is important for K-12 teachers to listen to because it talks about how big tech companies and how their ideas might not fit into a real classroom setting. It then goes into the business and politics with school technology programs and what can happen if schools rely on technology too much within a classroom. They then go into talking about which learning tools to use and which ones could affect classroom behaviors and instead encourage teachers to question and choose for themselves what’s best for their students.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think that listening to episode 177 of this podcast, The Opposite of Privatization is Publicization would be beneficial for K-12 teachers because it highlights a lot of the issues that I think many public school teachers feel, but might not know how to put into words. The episode is an interview with educator Jonathan Gurko, and he starts it out by saying that neoliberalism and the current emphasis on markets in deciding what happens with public policy has been a demonstrable failure. He outlines a few of his solutions to this, namely being that schools need to be restructured so that education is treated as a way to increase human flourishing rather than now, where it is treated as a good that people consume that happens to be funded by tax dollars. He also says that an increase of federal funding for public schools would reduce the burden on state and local governments. Another one of his main points is that if a public school is in a district where houses are very expensive, that the insanely high barrier to entry that that creates makes it so that those schools are not really public. In conclusion, this is a very interesting listen, and I think would be beneficial for K-12 teachers to listen to for these reasons.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I really liked this podcast and originally picked it because it began with asking the question of how we as teachers can make a difference in life. Its main point was that teacher-student relationships need to be more than teaching a curriculum and connected this to critical pedagogy. Their other main point was a progressive approach to education allows teachers to care about their students and see them as more than just their academic capabilities which will help foster overall moral growth. I couldn’t agree with this more as every kid in school isn’t only learning about subjects, but also who they are and who they want to be. Support from a teacher, a role model that they see almost everyday, is a necessity for this time of growth. In this podcast, Jennifer and Jack question if this critical aspect of education is being forgotten about as AI comes into the picture as a tool to teach students. I think any teacher could benefit from this reminder that what makes education so powerful is the impact supportive teaching makes on young kid’s characters.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I listened to the podcast Silicon Valley’s Vision for Schools is Trapped in a Cold War Fantasy. It could be beneficial for P-12 teacher's to listen to this, because it poses the idea that the advancing technology, particularly AI, is threatening to the authenticity of teaching. It is devaluing human teachers, and insinuates that these visions are usually driven by profit and techno-utopianism rather than pedagogical needs.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think that the coming to America episode hit me more than the others because being the child of immigrants I often had experiences at school where It seemed the goal was to assimilate me. A question I'd ask is how we could really ensure ALL students feel culturally included when there are so many cultures out there, also how to include them with their peers without trying to make them fit in a box.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Emma Lucius-MillimanMarch 2, 2026 at 10:09 AM

    My assigned podcast was the Silicon Valley Vision for Schools is Trapped in a Cold War Fantasy. It was an interesting concept to hear the computers would be teaching instead of humans. However I think the podcast was very surface level to how AI would actually be affecting our school system. The current plan is not to put robot teachers but instead to add AI knowledge into the curricula so that students would be more prepared to become data center workers. I think we all know that robot teachers is highly unlikely. But to say that we are trapped in the cold war sounds like a fear tactic that would be used during the cold war. We're not just devaluating the need for teachers, we're devaluating the human experience by already having a set job path before its the individuals decision.

    ReplyDelete
  21. One thing I thought was interesting from the podcast “The Opposite of Privatization is Publicization” (#177) was the idea that instead of replacing public schools with private ones, we should focus on improving public schools. The speakers talked about how privatization can take money and resources away from public schools, which can make things harder for students and teachers. I thought that was a good point because public schools are meant to help everyone in the community.
    One question I had while listening was how schools are actually supposed to improve public education if they already don’t have enough funding or resources. It sounds like a good idea, but I wonder what schools or the government could really do to make public schools better.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think that P-12 teachers would benefit from listening to this podcast, "Teachers Speak Out", because it offers perspectives on the pressures of standardized testing and systemic challenges, as well as how to navigate professional pushback and teaching charge of their responsibilities as educators. I thought that this episode was interesting especially when they discussed how teachers are often treated as technicians rather than intellectuals. It is important for teachers to know that critical thinking is necessary to foster the same in their students.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I watched the episode “the kids are alright” from the “have you heard?” podcast. It was about student activism and discussing a book by Aaron G. Fountain Jr. that discusses the history of student activism and the similarities to today's student activism. They pointed out how most protests and underground newspapers were blamed on an “outside agitator”, from the communist party during the cold war to ANTIFA today. A question I have is why the cycle of teen activism - misunderstanding parents keeps repeating. Many parents/grandparents of today's youth protested during the cold war and the war in the middle east, yet those very same people oppose present day student activism. It’s fair to think maybe the people opposing student activism today were also opposing it back then but I don’t think that’s the overarching theme of this. I think I’d like to see the statistics on people who approve of teaching about civil rights movements and other activism in schools compared to the amount of people that approve activism when students are the ones doing it.
    I watched the episode “the kids are alright” from the “have you heard?” podcast. It was about student activism and discussing a book by Aaron G. Fountain Jr. that discusses the history of student activism and the similarities to today's student activism. They pointed out how most protests and underground newspapers were blamed on an “outside agitator”, from the communist party during the cold war to ANTIFA today. A question I have is why the cycle of teen activism - misunderstanding parents keeps repeating. Many parents/grandparents of today's youth protested during the cold war and the war in the middle east, yet those very same people oppose present day student activism. It’s fair to think maybe the people opposing student activism today were also opposing it back then but I don’t think that’s the overarching theme of this. I think I’d like to see the statistics on people who approve of teaching about civil rights movements and other activism in schools compared to the amount of people that approve activism when students are the ones doing it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ignore second paragraph, i paste from google docs

      Delete

3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)

  What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...