What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding of what democracy is and/or can be? Do you have any thoughts about viewing this film at this moment in time?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3/18...What is Teaching? (rescheduled due to January ice storm)
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
-
React to this film. One possible topic is to relate this film to the recent CRT controversy.
I think the filmmaker is trying to convey just how fluid democracy can be highlighting how different people view it and how much it has changed over time. It was very interesting hearing different perspectives people have on democracy and how they believe it looks like in society or how it should look. Going to different countries and places to interview different people shows how vast democracy is as in a way that it is the same in many ways but also can have unique differences which I thought was very thought provoking for myself and how I view it. This film contributed to my own understanding of democracy by describing democracy to be something unfinished rather than a fixed system. It can look or be modeled in so many different ways which I knew to be true but this film further portrayed that idea. Viewing this film in the current state of society just highlighted how there are still ongoing problems similar to the ones mentioned in 2018 and growing ones as well.
ReplyDeleteAstra Taylor shows that democracy isn’t just about voting or having a government, but something messy and unfinished that people are always fighting over. The film made me realize how democracy has existed alongside things like inequality, mass incarceration, and colonialism. What stood out to me was the idea that democracy can take many shapes outside of our government and voting process; like in protests, social movements, and everyday people speaking up. Watching this film right now feels really relevant because a lot of people don’t trust the system anymore, and it made me think more about who actually has power and how democracy could be better for the people rather than the system.
ReplyDeleteAstra Taylor seems to say that democracy isn’t a "done" thing, nor is it a stable system of government; rather, she claims it’s a continuous struggle for power, equality, and for people to participate in governance. My view of how democracy operates through the democratic process and not just the institution or electoral processes which are often associated with democracy. Democracy can be established through protests, mutual assistance, unionization of workers, and public discourse. Democracy can only operate effectively when there is economic justice for all, otherwise it is hollow to have political equality. I think the film shows us that democracy is something that we must continually build and defend ourselves, and cannot be assured of simply because of the constitution or governmental structures in place.
ReplyDeleteI think the main message the filmmaker was trying to convey is that there is no clear definition of democracy. Everyone has their own interpretation based on where they are from, how they were raised, educated, excluded or included, represented or oppressed. I really appreciated how there were so many different individuals represented in this documentary from different parts of the US, different political beliefs, and different countries all with unique experiences and perspectives. It really displayed one of the dilemmas of democracy: how can the government satisfy the people, represent the people, and help everyone when there is such an array of human experiences? I found the conversations and issues discussed in this film overwhelming at times because it does feel like there is no solution. Viewing the film at this moment in time in the face of such big political and social issues where it feels like there is inequality everywhere, it was comforting to hear individual people be kind, wise, and have dreams to improve the country and look out for people who are mistreated. One line that stood out to me was the enthusiastic Greek professor who said democracy “ha[s] to ensure the wellbeing of the people. We forget that.” This in conjunction with the students interviewed was hard to hear as a future teacher. The students talked about how school should be a “home away from home” yet they are punished for trying to speak up, and they feel like they have no possible say in their school or their school district. This definitely is changing my impression of how democracy and schools are interconnected because schools should not be teaching students to lose faith in democracy before they’ve even graduated.
ReplyDeleteI think what the filmmaker was trying to convey about democracy is that it's definition is dependent on the person. People all have their own desires and necessities, and citizens want a functioning democracy that meets their needs. Watching this film made me realize that depending on how mistreated you are in your government, determines how hard you need to fight for a fair democracy. Watching the film also made me realize that democracy is entirely dependent on the people, their needs, and is meant to serve and uphold them. A society that helps mostly the elite is corrupt and dysfunctional. I think watching this film at this moment in history is very important, as there is a terrible government in place at the moment which fights against the minorities of its society. We need to reevaluate our democracy and reorganize it to where it actually serves the people.
ReplyDeleteIn the film by Astra Taylor, democracy is not just the voting system or the form of government, but it is a process that needs to be filled with participation and accountability. The power and inequality of the society have been highlighted in the movie, which shows that democracy does not work for everyone.
ReplyDeleteWhat was new to me from the movie was the way the movie highlighted the connection between the economy and democracy. Democracy has been given insight to the viewers through the movie that it is a process that needs to be filled by the people, rather than it being automatic. The relevance of the movie can be understood from the current political divide that needs to be filled by answering the question of who democracy works for.
The filmmaker is trying to tell us that democracy is an on going struggle and it is not complete. Something new to me is starting to understand how complex and unstable the concept of democracy is. Democracy is so much more than politics. You can find democracy in so many different things like schools, workplaces, media, families, and so more. I think this is super important to learn, especially right now with what is happening to our country. People are trying to protest peacefully which is something democracy encourages but it is no longer safe to do so. People need to learn what exactly democracy is because it shapes everyone's lives even if they don't realize it.
ReplyDelete-Rebecca Mann
DeleteI think the message the filmmaker is trying convey is that even though we live in a democracy by definition, all the people's thoughts she included in the film think otherwise. I noticed that all the statements from all the people she included all feel that their voices will never be heard and the government only listens to a certain demographic and there is nothing anyone can do to change it. This system we have lived in for so many years has never been what it is supposed be, power vested by people. The kids that were asked if they feel like they have a voice helped me put into perspective what it may feel like to anyone who speaks up for injustice just to be ignored and pushed away. I think this whole film truly conveys how much people fight everyday just to be treated equally.
ReplyDeleteThe filmmaker shows how democracy can change and look different to different people. It was interesting and new to me to hear the many opinions about what democracy looks like in society and what it should be. The main message of the film is that there is no single definition of democracy. Instead, people understand it based on their background, experiences, education, and whether they have felt included, represented, or excluded. From what I gathered its all based on people perceptions and further contributed to my understand that democracy is very complex and frankly unstable leading to inequalities. While viewing the film it made me reevaluate the concept of democracy and if we are truly living in a democracy.
ReplyDeleteAstra Taylor's point is that democracy is a constant struggle for power and who gets a voice. I really liked her point about how democratic participation can feel superficial when our vote doesn't seem to immediately translate into improvements in people’s lives. I think we have all thought about that at one time or another. At the same time, I found myself questioning the film’s tendency to treat capitalism as inherently opposed to democracy. While economic inequality can certainly distort political influence, capitalism has also historically supported democratic development by fostering a large middle class and encourages independence from centralized authority and provides us with multiple centers of power outside the state. The problem isn't inherently capitalism. I believe it's institutional failure that allow economic power to dominate politics. This film is definitely relevant to the frustrations many people feel at this point in time in the USA, but it may also overlook how competition and market participation have historically reinforced one another and contributed largely to our success and prosperity.
ReplyDeleteThe filmmaker is trying to convey that democracy is not a static, unchanging thing, but that it is an idea that has changed and developed across time and as societies have developed. Something that was new to me was the explanation of Plato's book Democracy and the ideas in it. I have heard of the book before but I did not know that it's critique of democracy is because people aren't qualified to lead themselves. The first part of this film makes me think about how undemocratic the US really is, with the Black representative who's name I can't remember talking about his experiences in the fight for civil rights, and how far the country still has to go in order to truly heal the legacy of slavery and the current issues of systemic racism.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker makes it clear that she views democracy as a constantly changing and shifting cycle, with a definition that warps and is built over time through its role in politics. This film made me think about the current state of the government. Due to this constant change, it is easier for people to forcefully change and manipulate that definition to their own benefit. This makes the definition of democracy unclear, the more it changes the further the definition gets from the original purpose.
ReplyDeleteI believe this film is trying to portray how complex democracy really is in our society. Its not just as simple as just putting your vote in, but it is far more complex. Democracy requires active participation and expressing your opinions. We see in the film lots of protesting and people expressing how they want a change in society. Something that was news to me was how important having a voice is when it comes to democracy, but also how many voices get overlooked. The film contributed to my understanding by showing how democracy can be apart of everyday life. It also showed me and opened up my eyes to many different issues we have and how democracy is used to talk about these issues. I believe that a lot of issues shown in the film are issues we have in current day so its eye opening to how democracy is used currently in the U.S.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to convey democracy as a multifaceted system that goes far beyond “giving power to the people.” An important part of the documentary were the diverse amount of interviewees who each had their own idea of what democracy meant. All the different answers gave me a new appreciation for how truly complex the concept of democracy is. The perspectives that stuck with me the most were the ones that talked about the relationship between democracy and capitalism. Those two systems have always been at odds in my mind, given that capitalism functions off of private ownership whereas democracy is, in theory, meant to benefit everyone. How do we prevent a democratic government from becoming influenced away from the needs of the people by the wants of corporations when capital equals power? I have a hard time imagining a world without capitalism since I’ve never lived in one, but I also can’t imagine how our society can keep functioning as it is.
ReplyDeleteWhat was new to me were some of the proposed democratic frameworks brought up by the Greek philosopher, particularly the one about an entirely randomized election. I’ve never really thought of random chance as democratic before.
Viewing this film at this moment in time felt extremely important given the current political situation in the United States. The documentary was like a reminder of what our nation’s core values are meant to be and how important it is that we are specific in the kind of democracy we want.
- Ginna D
DeleteI think that the filmmaker is trying to interrogate the true meaning of democracy, it’s a term that encompasses so much and such a wide history. She does this by surveying the Athenian origins of democracy against a variety of contemporary issues like the Syrian refugee crisis, modern Greek politics, American public schools, and the 2016 election. What stood out to me was the differing answers to “What is Democracy?” and how each individual's answer reflected the issues they were facing. One man said democracy is freedom when others described it as justice. It was particularly illuminating and disheartening to hear the group of students talk about their failed experiences with democracy when we have been discussing what exactly is the role of schools in society. The barber Ellie Brett did a great job of highlighting how impossible it is to reacclimate into society after serving a jail sentence, and how our current American “democracy” is structured in a way that perpetuates struggle for many while leaving them without a voice. Though the documentary debuted many years ago, all of the issues it discussed still remain incredibly relevant, and I wonder what we will have to do in order to create lasting change to our failing democracy.
ReplyDeleteI feel as if this documentary was made so we can see how democracy is not all about what's on paper and it's something that is easy to bend and play with, especially when you have the power or money to do so. It also pointed out how often manipulated democracy is. This film helped me see how democracy outside of America is and how it compares in huge ways. The film did a good job of pointing out that democracy can be found through protest and people simply constantly advocating during everyday life. Seeing this film now feels like we been stuck in a position for a while now and not much change has happened.
ReplyDeleteIn this documentary I think the director was trying to convey that democracy cannot be a single set of ideas, but is rather a product of continuous questioning and reshaping by the people. The film, instead of defining democracy, portrays it by showing various perspectives of the people, like the philosophers, the activists, and the common people, to demonstrate how democracy is a complicated matter. This film opened my eyes to the extent that democracy is a matter of power. People mostly connect democracy with voting and elections. Through this film, I learned that democracy and inequality can be present at the same time, which is a bit contradictory to the idea that democratic systems are inherently fair. Given the current political events and debates regarding rights and representation, watching this documentary has become more relevant than ever. It also got me thinking if we as a society actually live democracy or only talk about it.
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is that there are different goals to achieving democracy from person to person, where in the end everyone's trying to live their life. Though if anything, it seemed that in every situation there always seemed to be a need for equity and a question of equality, and that in all seems to be a problem of disparity --- the socratic question.
ReplyDeleteThere's the equity, the kids at school that just want to be able to eat a nice meal, and the barber that had to stand against the removal of the library, and Stavroula that just wants the opportunity of work, a wage, an education, to live a life that could support a family. Yet there are question the equality, that they feel they are being cheated out of their hard work as it's being given to those in need.
One part of the movie that really struck me about what we're going through right now is that our democracy really in the hands of corporations, and not the people themselves. This really reminded me about Citizens United v. FEC, where there's no expenditure limit on political broadcasts as long as it's "independent". Even though the money never goes directly to the government, the political voice that is heard in the end, is those of corporations, especially those with money.
While watching the film, I thought that all these people coming together for the same thing they believe in and taking a stand together to make it better for daily lives. Which is great and that democracy isn't just in numbers but only one person can make a huge difference but that there is power in numbers. Then even with democracy and the voting the people got screwed over and that made me think maybe democracy means nothing and power is in positions. Yet I know this isnt true but I would think in todays society that postion and power overrule democracy.
ReplyDeleteThe overall message I got from this documentary is that what democracy has become cannot be defined simply. It is a right for the people but it is also a system; one that can be manipulated. This manipulation has the potential to take away its basic rights from certain groups, which is something that has been reflected in history before. This was discussed as the two greatest examples of democracy, America and Athens, were strong societies dependent on slave labor. A common theme throughout all of the interviews was an overarching question about how to return to the principle values of democracy, highlighting its importance in a society. But also, how democracy and its values need to be reinstated as a whole because it is too broken to be fixed. I definitely think that this dissonance between trying to save something that needs reinvention is shown through all of the different perspectives of those featured who have had different experiences with democracy. I think that the most powerful points about the injustices within the system were proven by the black female students interviewed who shared that it doesn’t matter if they are brave enough to use their voice if society doesn’t value them first. It is the white middle and high class whose voices are respected and therefore, they are the ones who get to exercise democracy. However, this group is the most likely to disregard their rights because they are not motivated to change injustices that don’t affect them. Watching this documentary is so impactful considering the times we are living in. While listening to the woman at the end and her painful experience at the border I thought about the policies being enforced right now and all of the people living that harsh reality who don’t have a voice in what democracy has become.
ReplyDeleteI think the film making was trying to convey that democracy isn't just black in white. It's a multitude of complexities that come together to create an act of good that can unfortunately be easily abused. However the documentary highlights that there is power in numbers. Democracy cannot function without the power of the people. Even though a government may be corrupt, theres ways that democracy can influence the government to give the power back to its people. Overall I think the documentary was successful in showing the the layered onion that is democracy by explaining historical and current (for the time) context.
ReplyDeleteIn the film the general theme is that democracy is not a one and done deal. Democracy is ever changing from person to person and from time to time. There weren’t any topics that were completely new and foreign to me; however this film did a lot to expand on the knowledge I already knew. This film further cemented in my head that a person's entire being shapes how they view democracy: Their race, sex, sexuality, gender orientation, upbringing, and also location are just a few things that can make a person have a differing perspective from mine or my peers. I think the interviewing of different people around the world helped people understand the world outside the bubble that is the United States. A lot of the time the scope an average American has is limited to the events in the U.S. when there are broader opinions going on in every other part of the world. Seeing this film is the current nature of our society both where we’re at politically and as a people. We have the world at our fingertips and more information that even our grandparents could have ever imagined having at the touch of a button that has desensitized us and made us numb to the horrors around the world. Schools teach us that democracy is voting, contacting our congressperson, and maybe on occasion a protest. Democracy is so much more than that, it includes the words we say, the content we post, and protests that are happening all the time all around us. Protesting wasn't just the Boston tea party, women’s suffrage and the civil rights movement which society has made seem longer ago than it really was, protesting is an important right we should all exercise. This fil was very thought provoking and I enjoyed watching it.
ReplyDeleteI feel like they're trying to show us how, pretty much everywhere in the world, people are affected by democracy and how we can't really escape it. The film also highlights the negatives in democracy, it likes to constantly remind us that democracy arose around colonialism, economic exploitation, and overall tyrannical governments. What felt new to me is knowing how much damage democracy can do to countries, and the historical significance of it. Democracy shouldn't be treated as something that is morally correct and should be the guideline everyone in the world should stick to. I feel like it's a lot more that goes into it that we take for granted. My thoughts on this film can kind of formulate into a question: Will we see a decline in the demonstration of democracy around the world?
ReplyDeleteI think the filmmaker is trying to convey that everyone sees democracy differently, and democracy can be shown in many different forms. The film allows us to think of democracy outside of the formal terms and think beyond that and imagine how democracy can make its way into our everyday lives. This film not only shows why democracy is important in our everyday lives, but it is also a call to action to advocate for people to push for a democratic nation. During this film I noticed that all voices are represented, from children to formerly incarcerated individuals, which is something we don’t see in films such as this one. I also noticed that the film shows that democracy is an ongoing process and is still not obtained in certain parts of the world. This film revealed to me that democracy is not going to come easy, but with advocacy and support, everyone will be able to experience democracy.
ReplyDeleteI think it shows that democracy isn’t just about voting, it’s about people actually having a voice and some real power in society. One thing that stood out was how it showed that not everyone has the same level of influence, even in democratic countries. The film helped me see that democracy is always changing and depends on how involved people are. Watching it now feels important because a lot of countries are still arguing about fairness, rights, and participation, and the movie reminds us that democracy works best when people stay involved and speak up.
ReplyDeleteI think this shows that democracy has been around for a long time and seems to be in the peoples hands. Voting is a big thing that we think of when it comes to democracy, but the voice of the people seems to have a large effect on things as well. It was nice that this documentary covered people through different walks of life and their point of view on democracy.
ReplyDeleteI like how Astra Taylor conveys true democracy is an everchanging experiment rather than a static achievement. The film argues most modern systems are commonly oligarchies or plutocracies, enforcing a revaluation of equity & authority. This film is crucial especially now during a time of rampant inequality & populism & serves as a reminder of how fragile democracy can be, & how it's under "constant threat" by the wealthy.
ReplyDelete